default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

America doesn't need guest workers

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Friday, March 8, 2002 10:00 pm | Updated: 2:24 pm, Mon Mar 19, 2012.

Here we go again. Like the proverbial bad penny, President George W. Bush's amnesty/guest worker programs keep turning up.

Note that I refer to "Bush's programs" because, with the exception of Latino advocacy groups and the president's thoroughly intimidated staff, few others muster up any enthusiasm.

The latest cipher to join the Bush choir is Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge.

The Arizona Republic reported that Ridge's team and Mexican negotiators are pounding out a deal to increase the numbers of Mexicans working in the U.S.Joe Guzzardi

To get the maximum bang for his buck, Ridge is also diligently forging ahead with a plan to authorize Mexican trucks to operate north of the border zone.

Two months ago, I wrote that Mexican President Vicente Fox had not achieved any of his campaign goals. But as of today, Fox still has accomplished nothing domestically. Most obviously, Fox has not created the hundreds of thousands of new jobs he promised.

Hence, Fox's stature in the eyes of Mexico rests on whether he can influence Bush to ram through a guest-worker program. If Fox succeeds, he's a hero. Fail and Fox is just another in a long line of ineffective Mexican leaders.

The rub is that U.S. doesn't need guest workers. For every foreign worker who enters the U.S, an American worker suffers.

From Economics 101: More workers willing to work for less money means downward pressure on wages.

"It's a race to the bottom," said William Heffernan, a professor of rural sociology at the University of Missouri.

Until 20 years ago, meatpackers were unionized employees who earned $18 an hour adjusted for inflation. Now low-paid, nonunion workers from Guatemala and Mexico who start at $6 an hour staff meatpacking plants

"Employers can take advantage of these people because they can threaten to send them back," Heffernan said.

The old saw about "Americans just won't do these jobs" hangs on despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.

Look at the propaganda. "Death at the Wall" ran in Rolling Stone magazine. Written by former Wall Street Journal investigative reporter Dan Baum, the story tells a familiar tale about those who come north seeking a better life.

Baum, in the magazine's Letter from the Editor, said: "The people who walk across the desert to make beds at the Ramada Inn are the unsung heroes of American capitalism."

Missing from Baum's perspective is that providing for the welfare of Mexican citizens is the responsibility of the Mexican - not the U.S. - government.

That important observation aside, let's follow, as Baum does, the travels of "Arnaldo."

Arnaldo made it across. He's alive and well. In Baum's eyes, Arnaldo triumphed.

"He was working, hanging sheetrock for $11 an hour with his brother and a bunch of other guys from Cofradia (Mexico)," Baum wrote.

The problem is that $11 is about one-third of union scale.

For an investigative reporter, Baum didn't do much investigating. A quick Internet search took me to Gangbox, a site where carpenters dish out the inside scoop on their trade.

There I met Gregory A. Butler, a card-holding member of Local 608. Butler told me that illegal immigrants have severely impacted wages for Americas 5 million carpenters.

Contractors who bid out sheetrock jobs are frequently abusive to illegal aliens, Butler said. They often demand 100 boards per worker per day - about twice the normal production. The contractors bill out at union rates, pay less than half that rate and pocket the difference.

The ultimate irony is that those most opposed to a guest-worker plan should include MALDEF and LULAC. If those organizations had the best interests of Mexican workers at heart, they would be against more cheap labor entering the U.S.

Of course, MALDEF and LULAC have a quite different agenda, but that is another column.

If Bush gets his way, Arnaldo and his brothers better look over their shoulder. Soon, they'll be working for $8.

Joe Guzzardi, an instructor at the Lodi Adult School, has been writing a weekly opinion column since 1988. He can be reached via e-mail.

Comments about this column? Send mail to the News-Sentinel newsroom.


To subscribe to the Lodi News-Sentinel, fill out our online form or call our Subscriber Services Department at (209) 333-1400.

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Use your real name. You must register with your full first and last name before you can comment. (And don’t pretend you’re someone else.)
  • 2 Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually oriented language.
  • 3 Don’t threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
  • 4 Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything. Don't post unsubstantiated allegations, rumors or gossip that could harm the reputation of a person, company or organization.
  • 5 Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 6 Stay on topic. Make sure your comments are about the story. Don’t insult each other.
  • 7 Tell us if the discussion is getting out of hand. Use the ‘Report’ link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 8 Share what you know, and ask about what you don't.
  • 9 Don’t be a troll.
  • 10 Don’t reveal personal information about other commenters. You may reveal your own personal information, but we advise you not to do so.
  • 11 We reserve the right, at our discretion, to monitor, delete or choose not to post any comment. This may include removing or monitoring posts that we believe violate the spirit or letter of these rules, or that we otherwise determine at our discretion needs to be monitored, not posted, or deleted.

Welcome to the discussion.

Recent Comments

Posted 19 hours ago by Jien Kaur.

article: Letter: Ron Portal’s letters repeat the…

So very much the truth Mr Adams - but you forgot to make the mention of the man who spend the millions and finally discover that the Mr Oba…


Posted 19 hours ago by Michael Fiske.

article: Letter: Suggestions for committee appoi…

Ed, everybody knows JoAnne hates Bob. If you don't know that than you don't know squat! Open your eyes. She campaigned against two candidat…


Posted 20 hours ago by Jien Kaur.

article: Letter: Our leaders need to be better r…

The Mr Kindseth wrote that 'America’s attitude toward Royal Emperor Obama changed when he went from “We the People” to “Screw the People”' …


Posted 20 hours ago by Thomas Heuer.

article: Steve Hansen: Funding, researcher bias …

Skepticism is a smart way of saying "I DON'T KNOW." No more no less. It is not a lofty intellectual endeavor. It is used by the …


Posted 20 hours ago by Mike Adams.

article: Letter: Ron Portal’s letters repeat the…

A correct assumption instead: Mr. Portal, like most conservatives, utilize information that is not true and when they do use the correct …



Popular Stories



Your News

News for the community, by the community.

Mailing List

Subscribe to a mailing list to have daily news sent directly to your inbox.

  • Breaking News

    Would you like to receive breaking news alerts? Sign up now!

  • News Updates

    Would you like to receive our daily news headlines? Sign up now!

  • Sports Updates

    Would you like to receive our daily sports headlines? Sign up now!

Manage Your Lists