default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

My proposal reserves baseball's Hall of Fame for a truly select group

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Friday, January 16, 2009 10:00 pm

I have a proposal that would not only make the Baseball Hall of Fame's annual voting more interesting, but will also make the Hall a truly select place for the game's greatest players.

What I suggest is capping Hall of Fame membership at a specific number - let's say 300 players.

Once the number hits the 300 maximum, the membership also becomes frozen by position. If there are 20 first basemen, then at no time can there be more than 20. The same ceiling would be set for the rest of the position players, as well as starting and relief pitchers.

Once the upper limit of allowable players has been met, every time the Baseball Writers' Association of America votes to elect a player into the Hall using the standard 75 percent margin, another player must be voted out.

Let's say, for example, the BBWAA elects San Francisco Giant favorite, shortstop Omar Vizquel. If my concept were adopted, along with the vote that puts Vizquel in, another shortstop from a previous era must be voted out by, for the sake of the debate, a "50 percent plus-one" margin.

Would it be the 1902-1912 Chicago Cubs' Joe Tinker? Or would it be Rabbit Maranville, whose career spanned two decades with the old Boston Braves, Pittsburgh Pirates, Brooklyn Robins, St. Louis Cardinal and the Cubs?

Here's the crux of my plan: If writers don't agree on who exits, then no one enters! Thus the Hall remains reserved for the absolutely best players who ever took to the field.

My variation on Hall of Fame voting does two things, both good for the game.

First, it makes the annual selection process more interesting. Earlier this week, for example, the Hall announced that Oakland A's Rickey Henderson and the Boston Red Sox's Jim Rice were elected.

Henderson stole 1,406 bases (468 more than any other player), scored 2,295 runs (which also ranks first), collected 2,190 walks (second on the career list) and had 3,055 hits. Because of his accomplishments, Henderson, who played mostly left field during his career, was a shoo-in.

But, using my standards as a guideline, for Henderson and Rice to get in, two left-fielders must go. Might it be the Cards' Chick Hafey from decades ago, or from more recent years the Cubs' Billy Williams?

Since Henderson was an automatic choice, he would definitely replace a previous member. But what would happen to Rice? He may have gotten voted in, but whose slot would he take?

In short, using my upgraded standards, the Hall of Fame vote becomes two-dimensional.

And the debate surrounding the election becomes twice as intense since two questions would be under consideration.

Second, my system would keep the Hall permanently reserved only for baseball's best.

As the years pass, the quality of the players remaining among the 300 in the Hall would keep getting better. No matter how much time went by, the BBWAA would never kick out Babe Ruth, Ted Williams or Mickey Mantle.

As it stands today, with smaller parks, longer seasons, the designated hitter and computer print-outs of batter tendencies, amassing impressive career statistics is easier than ever.

Obviously, each player added makes the Hall less exclusive. What began in 1936 as a strictly elite club with five members (Ruth, Walter Johnson, Ty Cobb, Honus Wager and Christy Mathewson), the Hall of Fame has moved away from "cream of the crop only" status.

My process would avoid the embarrassment of allowing anyone but the most outstanding all-time players.

Currently mentioned as Hall contenders after their post-retirement five-year waiting period elapses are Roberto Alomar, Mike Mussina, Fred McGriff and John Smoltz.

All are great players whom any manager would covet. But if they make it to the Hall, most fans would agree that they represent second-tier players, not worthy of mention in the same breath as Ruth, Williams, Johnson or Mantle.

Under my system, none of them would ever get in the Hall because they would never replace anyone who is already there.

Eventually, some Hall icons might be displaced: Sandy Koufax, Reggie Jackson and Willie Stargell are three whose credentials are disputable.

Don't worry about what will become of those who might have to step aside.

Their plaques could be moved to a new Cooperstown wing constructed for the very purpose of honoring their baseball contributions.

Joe Guzzardi adds that he forwarded his proposal to the Hall of Fame and the BBWAA but expects that no one will pay any attention to him. Contact Guzzardi at guzzjoe@yahoo.com.

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Use your real name. You must register with your full first and last name before you can comment. (And don’t pretend you’re someone else.)
  • 2 Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually oriented language.
  • 3 Don’t threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
  • 4 Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything. Don't post unsubstantiated allegations, rumors or gossip that could harm the reputation of a person, company or organization.
  • 5 Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 6 Stay on topic. Make sure your comments are about the story. Don’t insult each other.
  • 7 Tell us if the discussion is getting out of hand. Use the ‘Report’ link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 8 Share what you know, and ask about what you don't.
  • 9 Don’t be a troll.
  • 10 Don’t reveal personal information about other commenters. You may reveal your own personal information, but we advise you not to do so.
  • 11 We reserve the right, at our discretion, to monitor, delete or choose not to post any comment. This may include removing or monitoring posts that we believe violate the spirit or letter of these rules, or that we otherwise determine at our discretion needs to be monitored, not posted, or deleted.

Welcome to the discussion.


  • posted at 2:46 am on Thu, Jan 22, 2009.


    Joe must have way too much time on his hands these days. Winter in Pittsburgh might be turning him into Jack Torrance."All work and no play makes Joe a dull boy."

  • posted at 9:21 am on Tue, Jan 20, 2009.


    Joe's missing the clear valley air.

  • posted at 2:23 am on Tue, Jan 20, 2009.


    anyone who has a vote for The Hall and makes statements to the effect "I'm not voting for the player this time but but next I will" or "he had a Hall-of-Fame career but I never liked the man so I'll never vote for him" should have their voting rights stripped. Print media writers' egos are embarrassing and their time of relevancy has passed.It's time to reassign who gets to vote players in.

  • posted at 11:16 am on Mon, Jan 19, 2009.


    That is the dumbest thing I ever heard of. Players of old are HOFamers of their era, the hall is for all to enjoy with players of present day and the past. You wonder why you write for the news-sentinel. How would you feel if you got eleted and then kicked out because of a number, not because someone was better than you....

  • posted at 2:26 am on Sat, Jan 17, 2009.


    A very interesting idea. The HOF is too diluted with mediocrity and favortism. As an addendum, lets give owners, GM's, and retired baseball players a HOF vote.


Recent Comments

Posted 6 hours ago by Ed Walters.

article: Letter: Ron Portal’s letters repeat the…

Kaur, with your slant on my posts [thumbdown]


Posted 8 hours ago by M. Doyle.

article: Letter: No one’s faith should be scorned

Nope, it was: "Three can keep a secret, if two of them are dead." He never implied killing anyone. Either way, what's your poi…


Posted 9 hours ago by Ed Walters.

article: Letter: Suggestions for committee appoi…

Fiske: Another new guy, you state JoAnne hates Bob, BS I know JoAnne and she is the most fair minded person on the counsel, and has been f…


Posted 10 hours ago by Shane Marcus.

article: ‘Taken 3’ takes a wrong turn with no ch…

This is an opinion, nothing more


Posted 10 hours ago by Ed Walters.

article: Letter: No one’s faith should be scorned

Ben Franklin also said, The best way to keep a secret between 3 people is to dispose of the first two.



Popular Stories



Your News

News for the community, by the community.

Mailing List

Subscribe to a mailing list to have daily news sent directly to your inbox.

  • Breaking News

    Would you like to receive breaking news alerts? Sign up now!

  • News Updates

    Would you like to receive our daily news headlines? Sign up now!

  • Sports Updates

    Would you like to receive our daily sports headlines? Sign up now!

Manage Your Lists