default avatar
Welcome to the site! Login or Signup below.
Logout|My Dashboard

Lodi Unified School District teachers get final layoff notices; may not know outcome for months

Font Size:
Default font size
Larger font size

Posted: Tuesday, May 17, 2011 12:00 am | Updated: 5:55 am, Thu May 19, 2011.

Most pink-slipped teachers have a box already set aside that they are quietly filling in preparation of the last day of school.

At home, they worry about whether they’ll have health coverage come summer and whether they should be scouring the classified ads.

Like districts up and down the state, hundreds of Lodi Unified School District certificated employees received preliminary layoff notices March 15, and final notices went out last week.

Unlike most employees in the private sector who lose their jobs right away when laid off, district employees did not know for sure until last weekend or later.

In the last three years, more than 500 pink slips have gone out in Lodi Unified. Though many employees have gotten their jobs back through attrition, the legal deadlines make it hard for teachers to make plans for next school year.

“I’m not going to lie, it’s frustrating to feel so unsettled. But waiting it out is simply the only option,” English teacher Renee Campbell said. “I’m finishing my fifth year teaching. And yet, I will be the ‘new teacher’ at whatever site I may be called back to, if I’m called back at all.”

Her name sits on the district’s master seniority list alongside 19 others with the same hire date: July 21, 2008.

It is from this list of dozens of names that administrators will base decisions on who to call back if a permanent position becomes available or funding is restored. In the meantime, some will wait while others have been released to seek employment elsewhere, all the while working to finish up the school year.

Budget reductions have forced districts up and down the state to eliminate programs and personnel.

Those efforts culminated with a week-long sit-in at the state Capitol and local rallies to call attention to ongoing cuts. After school Friday, a chartered bus took district staff to Sacramento to participate in the demonstration. On some Lodi Unified campuses last Wednesday, staff placed empty chairs in front of the school to signify the number of positions cut next school year.

And on Monday, they were anxious to see if Gov. Jerry Brown’s revised budget will restore education funding and possibly shed some light on the ultimate outcome — whether their layoff notices will be rescinded.


Campbell, who lives in Lodi, refers to the process of receiving pink slips year after year as living in limbo for she and her husband who is also a Lodi Unified teacher.

She was hired back as an English teacher at Bear Creek High School just days before the current school year started. She had received a pink slip the previous two springs, but was reassigned both years back to Lodi High.

“I love my students and have had a great year teaching, but never unpacked my files and made little effort to really become a part of the school,” Campbell says of the school year quickly coming to a close. “I think it was part self-preservation. I just didn’t want to get too attached when I foresaw this coming. I was heartbroken leaving my community at Lodi High and didn’t want to go through that again.”

Her husband, fellow teacher Brian Campbell, is at Tokay High School and loves it since it’s his alma mater. Due to pink slips, it’s his third school in three years.

They both received final notices last week.

“But, that aside, I am finishing up my best year teaching with students I really like,” Renee Campbell said. “I know with each year and with each new placement I am getting better and I am grateful for that.”

Elementary school teacher Aimee Ramsower said it is heart-wrenching to receive a pink slip over and over again. While hers is only probationary and she expects to have a job in the fall, she does not know where she’ll ultimately end up.

“Reassignment is a catastrophe, as far as I’m concerned. It causes upheaval for the teachers involved, the school site and more importantly the students,” she said.

Teachers with supplemental credentials are being reassigned to areas they are completely unfamiliar with while the positions they currently hold are being posted as available to those who are interested in participating in the transfer process, according to Ramsower.

“We are striving at all school sites to improve test scores and our teams are being dismantled year after year. We need continuity in our schools, and the current practices are not fostering that,” she said. “In my opinion if you’re not being laid off, you should stay right where you are. There is no valid reason in my opinion to shuffle everyone around.”

While disappointed they could be losing their jobs, some teachers have spouses with secure employment that makes receiving a pink slip a bit more palatable.

“While I suppose it would be nice to have a spouse with a job to fall back on, it’s also really nice to have a spouse that fully understands the situation and can offer real support, help,” Campbell said of her situation.

She says she, too, can be empathetic to her husband leaving a position he really enjoys. Brian Campbell works next door to his brother, is active in sports organizations, was asked to teach Advanced Placement psychology next year and was even was thinking of coaching basketball.

“However, he is hesitant to make commitments for fear he won’t be able to follow through because of this situation,” she said.

With the constant pink-slip merry-go-round, the couple has talked about leaving Lodi Unified or the profession altogether.

“It is discouraging to know you’re good at your job, but that it doesn’t make a difference on whether or not you get to keep your job,” Renee Campbell said.

Teachers are not the only employees affected.

School counselors and librarians were also among the certificated employees who received preliminary pink slips March 15. That includes those with a special teaching certification.

The district not only sent notices to those who hold the 177 positions approved by the school board in February, but also those hired since 2004, anyone who remains on last year’s rehire list, and second notices for temporary teachers. The rehire list includes those laid off last school year who have not started work back in the district.

By the numbers

Although state education has already forced them to approve the layoffs, trustees have publicly indicated a strong desire to return as many teachers as possible to the classroom, pending the state’s budget.

That has already happened in the Galt Joint Union Elementary School District. That school board last week previously approved moving forward with final layoff notices for 48 teachers, but three positions have since been restored.

“As the state’s budget conditions unfold ... additional layoff notices would be restored,” Superintendent Karen Schauer said in an email to employees Friday.

In Lodi Unified, this year’s layoffs will likely affect classrooms that are already overcrowded due to last year’s layoffs. Among the positions approved for elimination next school year:

  • 18 instructional coaches among all grade levels.
  • 14 school counselors.
  • 11 high school English teachers.
  • 8.5 full-time-equivalent elementary school vice principals.
  • Five high school physical education teachers.
  • Four high school librarians.
  • Four high school assistant principals.
  • Three high school social science teachers.
  • Two school nurses.
  • Both the vice principal and principal of the adult education program.

However, only 159 of the 177 notices approved in February went out last week, according to Michael McKilligan, assistant superintendent of personnel.

Last school year, almost 410 certificated positions were approved to be eliminated in the first step of the layoff process to deal with an anticipated $30 million shortfall.

In 2010, the district opted to use one-time federal stimulus money to save many of the positions, but those resources are unavailable this year.

Rehiring possibilities

Lyndon Blodgett, a Lodi High School counselor who also has a private practice as a licensed therapist, said those who received pink slips may be experiencing anxiety disorder with depressed mood.

“That mental health diagnosis really says it all: worry and sadness for several weeks about the unknown. Many will cope, but some will deal with lack of focus and be very distracted,” he said.

He has not personally received a layoff notice, but is close to many who have.

“The ripple effect of what they are going through certainly affects my thoughts, feelings and behaviors,” he said.

Campbell said she and her husband are trying not to get caught up in the politics or rumors about more state funding possibly becoming available.

“But it’s not easy. Every year we get to a point where we would almost rather just know (even if it’s negative) than to wait. It takes self-discipline to stay patient and positive,” she said.

There is always a chance that employees who land at the bottom of the seniority list could be rehired, even after the 2011-12 school year has begun.

Fewer than the 255 notices approved last spring were ultimately sent out when the district struck a deal with the teachers’ union and created an early retirement incentive. The idea behind it was if 100 teachers agreed to leave their positions early, it would make room for pink-slipped teachers to keep theirs.

And, in September, the personnel department called back 90 teachers as a result of concessions made between the union and the district. Among the contract’s stipulations was hiring back 40 previously laid-off teachers.

Ramsower understands the legalities of the notification process.

“Unfortunately, the human factor has been left out of the equation,” she said. “We are people who are being directly affected by decisions made by the powers that be. Yet we are left to hang in the balance with little information provided. The whole situation is unnerving.”

She will have a job somewhere in the district, most likely being moved from her five-year position as a sixth-grader teacher at Live Oak Elementary School to the junior high level.

“I have no idea where that will be since I’m being told that I will have to apply and interview for vacant positions — which makes no sense since I’m not voluntarily making a change, I’m being reassigned,” Ramsower said. “The district needs to involve teachers more in this process and remember that we all have the same goal, and that is to educate the children.”

In the meantime, the Campbells remain hopeful. After all, they met two years ago after receiving their first pink slips.

“I was going to move to Spain to teach, and he was thinking Thailand. For obvious reasons, we both decided to instead stay and wait it out. Our lives together have been in this limbo, and, you know, it still has been great,” Renee Campbell said.

“So, as frustrating as it is, we’ll stay. And hopefully, someday we can feel a bit more secure, make a little more money, and do the whole family and house thing,” she said. “Until then, we will wait it out with as much patience as we can muster. I suppose that’s one thing that teaching teenagers has helped us with: patience.”

Contact reporter Jennifer Bonnett at jenniferb@lodinews.com.

More about

More about

More about

Rules of Conduct

  • 1 Use your real name. You must register with your full first and last name before you can comment. (And don't pretend you're someone else.)
  • 2 Keep it clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually oriented language.
  • 3 Don't threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
  • 4 Be truthful. Don't lie about anyone or anything. Don't post unsubstantiated allegations, rumors or gossip that could harm the reputation of a person, company or organization.
  • 5 Be nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
  • 6 Stay on topic. Make sure your comments are about the story. Don't insult each other.
  • 7 Tell us if the discussion is getting out of hand. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
  • 8 Share what you know, and ask about what you don't.

Welcome to the discussion.


  • Darrell Baumbach posted at 8:57 pm on Tue, May 17, 2011.

    Darrell Baumbach Posts: 9403

    Doug... I was asking the union and the teachers to consider doing things differently. I also agree with you that other entities that are non union use seniority as well... as they are wrong as well. All I am asking for is merit... just like you told me the construction unions do. The teachers union however is completely different than all others... they represent the people who care for and educate our children. That is unique and special ... Do you not agree that our children should benefit from the best teachers. Why should the union get in the way.?

  • Darrell Baumbach posted at 8:50 pm on Tue, May 17, 2011.

    Darrell Baumbach Posts: 9403

    mike stated...Young teachers = good; old teachers = bad. Talk about age discrimination.

    Darrell stated...Sometimes the older more experienced teachers have more skills and should be retained.. but some older teachers are simply hanging on because of increased pay scale, benefits, and retirement ...not because they are better teachers... ( 2 teachers personally told me that, I assumed there were more)

    Mike... I hope you were not talking about what I said...

  • Doug Chaney posted at 8:31 pm on Tue, May 17, 2011.

    Doug Chaney Posts: 1232

    Darrell, do you think the organized (union) employees are the only ones using the seniority system? What about the unorganized, non-union and scabs that use the snitch system, nepotism, relative, friend and those who work extra hours and overtime for nothing system? Aren't they the employees that normally keep their jobs in the unorganized sector of labor employees? So why not scrutinize the scab employers for their obvious labor law violations also? And why the hatred of the unions in general?

  • Mike Adams posted at 6:15 pm on Tue, May 17, 2011.

    Mike Adams Posts: 1271

    Young teachers = good; old teachers = bad. Talk about age discrimination.

    Study after study show that younger teachers, although more enthusiastic, have severe difficulty in doing an effective job, particularly when placed in schools with lower socio-economic demographics. Most of these teachers become outstanding (with time and persistance), but it is also one of the reasons many younger teachers leave the job before year 5.

    Is it a seniority thing? Yes. Normally schools in areas where the socio-economic strata is higher generally have the teachers with the greatest amount of experience, and those schools do fine, some are exemplary.
    So the data shows that: older experienced teachers = better test scores, schools

    As I said earlier, you guys who are getting pink slipped, stick with it. You'll end up very good teachers. One day, soon, you'll be the one writing this. You'll get through it. Keep positive, stay prepared. If you worked all of last year or even as low as 3/4 of the previous school year, if a position becomes available and you have the credential needed, the district is obligated to call you back.

  • Darrell Baumbach posted at 4:56 pm on Tue, May 17, 2011.

    Darrell Baumbach Posts: 9403

    I agree with Mike, lay offs are horrible. I am sorry for anyone that faces this dilemma.
    It brings up a thought though... shouldn't students have the best teachers to teach them. Why is there seniority where merit has nothing to do with who gets fired or who gets to stay. The union must not care or have the best interest of the students in mind. In my view, what is best for the students are the best teachers available... not the oldest teachers who have seniority. Sometimes the older more experienced teachers have more skills and should be retained.. but some older teachers are simply hanging on because of increased pay scale, benefits, and retirement ...not because they are better teachers. Shouldn't the children's education be the biggest concern here even ahead of the valued older teachers? Maybe the older teachers who are near 65 should consider retiring now, while the pension is at its highest and make room for the quality younger teachers who contribute so much. Maybe the union can implement some type of merit system to evaluate teachers and get rid of the seniority system so the children can have the best teachers.

  • Mike Adams posted at 2:19 pm on Tue, May 17, 2011.

    Mike Adams Posts: 1271

    You guys stay strong!!! Many of you will find yourselves working next year. It's a hell of a way to start a career, a hell of a way to be treated, it's a hell of a way to show respect, getting laid off year after year. Many of you will return and when you return, you'll be higher on the list, and then it will be someone else who gets the letter. Schools full of kids need teachers. Many of the veterans are retiring. There will be a spot for you, trust me, I've been in your shoes. And one day, you'll find yourself retired to. Keep it up. A bit of advice you're free to follow....as the new school year approaches, get ready like you are going to work. When the school year starts and find yourself without a position still, be prepared as if you do. Get your stuff together, lessons preparedd. When the call comes (and for most of you it will) you can step in ready to go.



Popular Stories



Mailing List

Subscribe to a mailing list to have daily news sent directly to your inbox.

  • Breaking News

    Would you like to receive breaking news alerts? Sign up now!

  • News Updates

    Would you like to receive our daily news headlines? Sign up now!

  • Sports Updates

    Would you like to receive our daily sports headlines? Sign up now!

Manage Your Lists