Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Indexes

February 9th, 2010
February 8th, 2010
February 6th, 2010
February 5th, 2010
February 4th, 2010
February 3rd, 2010
February 2nd, 2010
ADVERTISEMENT
A man identifying himself as "Frank Earnest," left, and Bobby King, of Sacramento, argue over the subject of prayer in government institutions during a rally at the All Veterans Plaza in Lodi on Wednesday. "Frank Earnest," who is against opening meetings with prayer, argued with several Christian supporters of prayer, some speaking in tongues, before leaving the rally. (Dan Evans/News-Sentinel)

Two opposing sides gather to share views on Lodi council's prayer policy

By Maggie Creamer
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Thursday, August 6, 2009 6:22 AM PDT

While lining the sidewalk, 13-year-old Eddie Lopez and about 10 other kids chanted "Jesus said 'Amen,'" as others marched up and down the sidewalk with signs saying "Keep them separate" and "Not all Lodians 'R' Christian."

The debate about the Lodi City Council's prayer policy continued Wednesday night with about 400 people gathering for a prayer meeting near Carnegie Forum, and a couple dozen joining together for a counter rally.

While holding a sign quoting Colossians 3:17, Lodi resident Angela Lopez said she is tired of freedom being taken away from Christians.

"It's becoming harder and harder for the Christians. ... It's only because we support God that our country is as blessed as it is," Lopez said.

Her son, Eddie, also held a sign and a Bible.

"I came just to support Jesus," Eddie Lopez said. "Just for him to know I was here to support him."

As the Lopez's gathered to sing prayer hymns, Lodi resident Steve Weiner said he wanted to make sure the council knew there were two sides to this issue.

"We have Muslims, Sikhs, atheists and people of various faiths, and they can feel excluded and intimidated at council meetings if there is a prayer to one God, Jesus," Weiner said.

The two groups were reacting to a letter the Madison, Wis.-based Freedom From Religion Foundation sent to the council in May threatening to sue if the council did not enforce its own policy limiting prayers to "non-sectarian and non-denominational." The letter specifically mentioned 39 references to Jesus in 55 prayers the group watched online.

You need to upgrade your Flash Player This movie requires Flash Player 8 or greater.



The council decided it wanted to have a meeting to receive public comment and discuss the policy. The meeting was tentatively scheduled for Wednesday but was moved because the council needed to approve time-sensitive contracts. Mayor Larry Hansen announced Wednesday that the policy will be discussed at a special meeting Sept. 30.

In the meantime, the city clerk's office has started to call religious leaders to remind them about the policy.

The rally spilled over into the Lodi City Council meeting, even though the council members were not discussing the policy.

At the beginning of the meeting, people crowded into Carnegie Forum to listen to the invocation by the Rev. Alan Kimber of First United Methodist Church. He held a moment of silence before giving thanks for our country's freedom to express different beliefs.

At the end, he said "Amen," which was followed by some members of the crowd yelling "in Jesus' name." During the Pledge of Allegiance, some members also shouted the words "one nation under God."

The national group The Pray In Jesus Name Project sponsored the rally and had several religious leaders pray and give speeches to the group. People sang, chanted "Jesus," waved American flags and prayed throughout the rally.

Virginia Alejo clapped her hands and smiled during a hymn. She came from Stockton because she objects to governments taking Jesus' name out of prayers.

"This country was made because of our religion. ... The public has to be more aware. We should not be ashamed to be Christians," Alejo said.

Near the back of the crowd, Pastor Mike Abdollahzadeh of Lodi Avenue Baptist Church said this is one way the public can make its opinion heard.

"It's sad that we've gotten to the point where you squabble over prayer. ... Our nation would not be the same without faith, prayer and what God has done," he said.

Lodi United, a local group, led the counter-protest. Resident David Diskin formed the group last week because he wanted people to know that some Lodians do not support prayers before the council meeting.

Notable quotes

"Christians are the silent majority and eventually we have to stop being silent and stand up for our faith."
— Arlene Spilloway, Lodi

"Lodi's a pretty quiet place. Lodi is a conservative town. ... To see an issue like this take hold is pretty surprising but good."
— Suanne Minden, Lodi

"Jesus would take a backseat, strike up a conversation, listen to their heart and give them truth along the way."
— Tim Stevenson, senior pastor at Horizon Community Church

"Our country was founded on the basis that it wouldn't be pushed around and bullied by religion."
— Norm Lee, Lodi

"Many Americans wonder what's going on with the economy and school shooting, but we are taking away God and prayer."
— Richard Tafoya, Stockton

"After Proposition 8, it sent home that it needs to be more separate."
— Jessica Chernak, Sacramento

"Both sides will fight hard for what they think is right. It's not a one-night thing."
— Pastor Mike Abdollahzadeh, Lodi Avenue Baptist Church

As a Buddhist, Suanne Minden said she attended to support removing prayer from the meetings and replacing it with a moment of silence. She lives in Lodi but is a Canadian citizen.

"We don't have this type of issue in Canada," Minden said. "We believe in not crossing religion and government."

Describing herself as belonging to one of the few Jewish families in Lodi, 19-year-old Rachel Allen stopped by the rally because she knew that what she described as "conservative Lodi" would be in full force.

"I don't go to council meetings to be preached to. ... Why can't they have a non-denominational prayer? Why is it so important that Jesus' name has to be in it? We all believe in the same God," Allen said.

But not everyone who attended the rallies grabbed signs and joined the group.

Kimber said he walked through the gathering on his way to give the invocation, but said he did not want to attend because his view on the issue was different. He believes the current policy of non-sectarian and non-denominational prayers is good, if it is adhered to.

He also said many of the clergy he talked with did not attend the rally because it was organized by a group outside of Lodi with an extreme view.

"I think the clergy have a deep sense of commitment to each other and the city," Kimber said.

While standing between the two rallies, senior pastor Tim Stevenson of Horizon Community Church in Galt said he came to watch and listen.

"God's pretty big," he said. "I don't think he needs us to defend his name."

He wishes the energy spent by both groups at the rally could go toward bigger problems facing Lodi and the world, like the people standing in front of Salvation Army or the thousands of children who die daily from preventable diseases.

"There are too many things around the world that God told us to go out and do," Stevenson said. "We got our priorities in the wrong place."

Contact reporter Maggie Creamer at maggiec@lodinews.com or read her blog at www.lodinews.com/blog/citybuzz.

Reader Feedback

The Realist wrote on Aug 18, 2009 2:54 PM:

" I detest religious, gullible, dupes foisting their BS on others. Prayer has no place in government proceedings. If these gullible dupes have a need to display their hocus pocus in front of an audience, then save it for your day of rest, at your local house of horse pucky, and then give a Oscar/Grammy winning performance in front of flim flam men of cloth, and fellowship. Catholics, Christians are no better than Muslims, Jews, or any other such cults. The existence of God, Allah, Jesus, Mohammad are all just a pack of indoctrinated lies . . . period. I am sick of having this mystical crap perpetuated on me and my family. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 13, 2009 9:11 AM:

" Tazz wrote "I definitely believe in separation of church and state."

Tazz: Mee too. And thanks for clearing that up for me. That bumper sticker is right! Yikes! "

Tazz wrote on Aug 12, 2009 3:36 PM:

" Lodian--this was a tongue-in-cheek comment I made. I'm not serious of course. It would never happen, because, as I said, the Christian religious right would scream too much. I definitely believe in separation of church and state. I saw a great bumper sticker the other day which said, "The last time we mixed religion and politics people got burned at the stake." "

Contrapasso wrote on Aug 12, 2009 1:03 PM:

" To all of those who are offended by the mention of God or Divine Providence or Creator in the constitution and the Declaration of Independence:

Do you think we should rewrite them so no one is "offended"?

It seems that tolerance, maturity, and respect for the principles upon which this country was founded go by the wayside when someone gets "offended."

Ridiculous.....If you don't like prayer, ignore it. Get over yourselves. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 12, 2009 12:14 PM:

" Tazz: That's why there should be separation of church and state. The cc meetings should be about city business, not making sure to have everyone say a prayer before the meeting. "

Tazz wrote on Aug 12, 2009 11:57 AM:

" I have a proposal: At the next cc meeting, let's have a Buddhist monk offer a chant to Buddha; a Rabbi offer a prayer to Yahweh; a Muslim offer a prayer to Allah, and a Wiccan offer a prayer to the Great Goddess. All of these religious groups live in Lodi. I will bet money that if this happens, the Christians will scream bloody murder. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 12, 2009 10:10 AM:

" Brian is lost again. :-) "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 4:44 PM:

" Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:56 AM:

"I don't know how Lodian can expect me to believe she would protest a Hindu
offering a prayer at a cc meeting."

Why? Do you think I'm Hindu? "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 4:42 PM:

" What argument? Is there an argument on the topic here? lol! "

Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:58 AM:

" Here we see Lodian implying I am Dyan too just to distract us from her ignorance and rants. and she's losing the argument. "

Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:56 AM:

" I don't know how Lodian can expect me to believe she would protest a Hindu
offering a prayer at a cc meeting. She would insist that the prayer go on because he is a member of the community
and it is not only about God but his culture too. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:53 AM:

" I'm sure the next cc meeting at HSS will again bring out the freaks. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:51 AM:

" dyan: I think you meant to address your other handle, Brian. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:50 AM:

" Brian wrote "There are a lot of people who believe in prayer that aren't
religious."

To whom are they praying? lol! "

dyan wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:48 AM:

" I have to caution you again, Lodian. Stick with the facts and not the name calling. One more outburst and I'll have to remove you from the courtroom. LOL "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:46 AM:

" Brian: You are having trouble with comprehension again. Try to read comments in context, if you are able, and that will help. You may have to read the comments more than once so you can "get it". Sometimes people like you have this sort of trouble. Just hang in there.

Christians should not be complaining that they are being denied any rights at the cc meeting because if that's the road they want to go down then they must say that other religions are being denied as well. The point is that Christians cannot use that line as they are the ones that have been praying at the cc meeting all along, while denying others. One might say that Christians are denying other religions their right to speak/pray. In the end, it's all wrong as there should be a separation between church and state. And, yes, praying at a cc meeting is mixing the two. "

Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:39 AM:

" Lodian wrote:

There are no freedoms being taken away from Christians if a prayer is not said before a cc meeting.

-Lodian,
How is other religions are being denied rights at cc meetings because they can't pray at the meeting but Christians
aren't being denied rights if they can't pray at the meeting? You see my point about your double standards?

Lodian wrote,
Many other religions, besides Christians, have been neglected by the cc and their rights have been denied.

-Yes I understand you are a proponent of furthing the denial of rights to Christians, and Christians are out of line when they protest. "

Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:30 AM:

" Lodian acknowledges that other religons are being denied their religious freedom
at cc meetings and now we are in the midst of Christians getting the same treatment if the Freed From Religon Foundation gets their way. It's all because of a little prayer. But she cheers them on anyway. "

Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:23 AM:

" Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 12:10 AM:

" It always amazes me that a lot of the same far right wingnuts that are in favor of less government in our lives are all about making sure their church is involved in government. Weird. "

-How is a little prayer at a cc meeting
an act of church involved in government?
One does not have to attend church in order to pray. There are a lot of people who believe in prayer that aren't
religious. "

Brian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 8:18 AM:

" Lodian wrote:
Many other religions, besides Christians, have been neglected by the cc and their rights have been denied.

I know Lodian. And now you are a proponent of denying rights to Christians at cc meetings. It's funny how you make Angela Lopez out to be a kook when she says Christians are being denied rights and then you go on to say other religons are denied rights
and Christianity can soon join the list.

Oh, but heaven forbid we call Lodian on her double standards. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 12:10 AM:

" It always amazes me that a lot of the same far right wingnuts that are in favor of less government in our lives are all about making sure their church is involved in government. Weird. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 12:05 AM:

" ...

"It's only because we support God that our country is as blessed as it is," Lopez said."

Thank God for our blessings in guiding our forefathers to make sure church is separate from state. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 11, 2009 12:01 AM:

" Again...

"While holding a sign quoting Colossians 3:17, Lodi resident Angela Lopez said she is tired of freedom being taken away from Christians."

One can completely adhere to Colossians 3:17 without speaking a Christian prayer out-loud before a Lodi cc meeting. There are no freedoms being taken away from Christians if a prayer is not said before a cc meeting.

No one has yet to explain how the freedom of Christians are being taken away at the Lodi cc meetings. The reason is that the statement holds no water and cannot be backed with facts. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:54 PM:

" Brian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:24 PM:

" Perhaps Lodian could care less that these people have to have church services in secret places to avoid further persecution. And how can she conclude that Angela Lopez doesn't know people in this situation? "

Um, because the topic is clearly spelled out for us here and that is what was being discussed. I know you have a hard time focusing Brian, but don't blame your failures on others. Stand up and take the blame for your own shortcomings. Now, pay attention. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:52 PM:

" Brian wrote "Here Lodian, take a look. Oh but heaven forbid you step outside of your little lilly A$$ world for a moment."

Brian: Will you always be lacking class and character? "

Lodian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:42 PM:

" Brian: Try harder to focus dear. What rights are being taken away from Christians if the cc meetings do not have an opening prayer? Shouldn't other religions be complaining? Most cc meetings open with a Christian prayer. Many other religions, besides Christians, have been neglected by the cc and their rights have been denied. Can you comprehend this, Brian/dyan? "

Brian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:29 PM:

" And OTH could also care less about people that may have first hand knowledge of persecution and they want to share their stories because they are worried it could happen in Lodi. "

Brian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:24 PM:

" Perhaps Lodian could care less that these people have to have church services in secret places to avoid further persecution. And how can she conclude that Angela Lopez doesn't know people in this situation? "

Brian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:19 PM:

" http://www.persecution.com/

Here Lodian, take a look.

Oh but heaven forbid you step outside of your little lilly A$$ world for a moment. "

Brian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:13 PM:

" Lodian wrote,

What freedoms are being taken away from Christians? "

-Evidently Lodian is not aware of all the Christians being persecuted all over the world. Perhaps a visit to the voice of the martyrs website will open
her eyes to this reality. "

Brian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:09 PM:

" OTH,

So people who don't live in Lodi and don't attend church in Lodi, but attend church somewhere else, and have a business in Lodi or do business in Lodi should not be allowed to speak their peace in Lodi about this issue? Is this your position?

What other people do you feel are not allowed to speak their peace about this issue in Lodi? "

Lodian wrote on Aug 10, 2009 3:25 PM:

" Brian: The biggest religious freak we've ever seen on these blogs (he who shall remain nameless) openly admitted that he doesn't go to church, so your point is meaningless. "

OTH wrote on Aug 10, 2009 11:38 AM:

" Brian

If the business owners attend church in Lodi fine. If not go home. And that was about the lamest excuse you could come up with! "

Lodian wrote on Aug 9, 2009 1:45 PM:

" <<< crickets >>> "

Lodian wrote on Aug 8, 2009 7:12 PM:

" ...

"While holding a sign quoting Colossians 3:17, Lodi resident Angela Lopez said she is tired of freedom being taken away from Christians."

What freedoms are being taken away from Christians? "

Lodian wrote on Aug 8, 2009 7:00 PM:

" Lodian wrote "Removing prayer from the cc meetings in no way means those in favor do not believe."

Brian wrote "-Perhaps, But no one will argue that some of these people don't attend church very often or have a Bible in their house."


----------------


Brian: Oh, be serious! I guarantee you that some of the people turning out downtown in favor of prayer at the cc meetings have not seen the inside of a church in quite some time. I bet some of them couldn't tell you the last time they read a bible verse. I've seen plenty of hypocrites on both sides so don't go getting all righteous on us. "

Brian wrote on Aug 8, 2009 10:05 AM:

" OTH wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:44 PM:

" Why doesn't everyone who doesn't live in Lodi go home and let us solve this by ourselves? This is our business and no on elses and I'm sure we are adult enough to find a solution. "

-Well OTH,
Many people own a business or do business in Lodi but don't live in Lodi.
That being said.... "

Brian wrote on Aug 8, 2009 8:36 AM:

" Lodian wrote,

Removing prayer from the cc meetings in no way means those in favor do not believe. "

-Perhaps,
But no one will argue that some of these people
don't attend church very often or have a Bible in their house. "

bug wrote on Aug 7, 2009 4:33 PM:

" Why does Christians insist on praying in Jesus' name? 1. We become a christian by confessing his name [Romans 10:9] 2. Jesus said in [John 14:14] If ye shall ask anything in my name, I will do it. 3.Jesus said in Matthew 10:33] But whosoever will deny me before men, him I will also deny before my Father. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 7, 2009 2:35 PM:

" LodiFreeThinker: How do you see this issue being settled (regarding prayer at the cc meetings)? "

Lodian wrote on Aug 7, 2009 2:34 PM:

" dyan: You are not addressing what I wrote on Aug 6 @ 11:58pm. I can only surmise that you did not understand it or that you just want to skip over it and attack me with some other sidebar issue for some bizarre dyan reason. lol "

Lodian wrote on Aug 7, 2009 2:31 PM:

" dyan: You are not addressing what I wrote. "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 7, 2009 11:54 AM:

" dyan, thank you very much. I believe people can disagree and still hold rational, potentially productive, discourse.

Often it seems that people want to disprove that notion, but I'll keep the hope alive. :) "

dyan wrote on Aug 7, 2009 9:33 AM:

" Godd argument, LFT. For once, someone has a well-thought-out position on these blogs. "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 7, 2009 9:28 AM:

" Lodi is often thought of a backward, right wing extremist town. I know a few people like that, to be sure, but let’s not let that image stand. Let us show the world we can be better. We have a strong community with a lot to offer to our citizens, and to the outside world. Let’s be a model for democracy in our modern world, and let’s continue offering to all of our citizens, life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 7, 2009 9:28 AM:

" dyan said: How is a prayer at a council meeting an "establishment of religion?"
It's not an establishment itself. Also, the city has made no law that respects an establishment. If it were any different, then we wouldn't be marching in front of Carnegie Forum, we would be suing.
The issue instead is about our local government acknowledging a religion above other beliefs. That is not fair or just and it's not what I should expect from my elected leaders.
Government works best when the citizenship is involved. We want people, from all over our community to participate. We can't exclude people based on their beliefs and expect to make effective, informed decisions that work toward the betterment of the community as a whole.
A good step would be to maintain a secular stance in our laws, our courts and our government meetings. This isn't to say that our government should ignore the churches. In order to be effective, the council should have good relationships with as many of the local communities, religious and non-religious, as possible.
Thomas Jefferson said "Commerce with all nations, alliance with none, should be our motto." "

dyan wrote on Aug 7, 2009 6:53 AM:

" Lodian: As an attorney, you know the separation of church and state was created by the courts. How is a prayer at a council meeting an "establishment of religion?" Only in the minds of a secular liberal. I guess Congress is "establishing a religion" when they open with a prayer. "In God we Trust" on money? Pure evil. "

dyan wrote on Aug 7, 2009 6:48 AM:

" "pork chop is a myth": God. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 6, 2009 11:58 PM:

" What some do not seem to understand is that this is a separation of church and state issue. Some seem to think that since many are insisting that prayer be removed from the cc meetings that those in favor are rejecting God. This is simple not true. Removing prayer from the cc meetings in no way means those in favor do not believe. "

pork chop wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:34 PM:

" All Gods and religions are a myth."FAITH". That word said it all.Anybody who believes in an afterlife I put in the same catagory as the people that believe Star Trek is real.They might be wierd but it is what makes them happy.My son still believes in Santa Clause but im not going to burst his bubble . if the councel wants to believe, and thats what drives there boat, then so what.If you dont believe then dont participate in the prayer,its not a big deal. "

OTH wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:44 PM:

" Why doesn't everyone who doesn't live in Lodi go home and let us solve this by ourselves? This is our business and no on elses and I'm sure we are adult enough to find a solution. "

Caliwings wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:53 PM:

" DO SOME RESEARCH YOU IGNORANT MORONS! CHURCH DOE NOT EQUAL STATE!!!! "

Caliwings wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:52 PM:

" ...... WE ARE NOT IRAN!!! "

Caliwings wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:47 PM:

" .... WE ARE NOT IRAN!!! "

Caliwings wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:46 PM:

" WE ARE NOT IRAN!!! "

dogs4you wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:31 PM:

" dogbark, I believe you have Moses confused with Fred Flintstone, or maybe Barney Rubble. "

4AStrongLodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:24 PM:

" I was all prepared to stand up for separation of church and state, but then those pastors started speaking in tongues and I quickly changed my view. I knew God must be sending a message through them. It was divine intervention!

Praise Jesus! That's Jesus with an "H" sound at the beginning for all the people that T&C wants deported (even if they're U.S. citizens). "

dogbark wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:01 PM:

" stuckin, give me just about ten minutes here, then check wikipedia. You'll find Moses actually rode on a dinosaur; used it in a gravel pit to lift rocks, too. "

dogs4you wrote on Aug 6, 2009 4:38 PM:

" stuckinlodi, For all the info you could ever want to know about dinosaurs, Mr. Google is your source, just type it in and viola, instant information. "

stucknlodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 4:16 PM:

" shockedinlodi, LodiFreeThinker, thanks for the tidbit of info. anytime anyone starts talking about religion, i always throw out that question. I am a religous person, went to one of the private schools here in Lodi, but the dinosaur or behemoth as the Bible says, has always baffled my mind. In private school they never talk about it to my knowledge, its been a long time since I was in private elementary school. So i keep asking to see what others say. "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 6, 2009 4:15 PM:

" dogbark said
"...all but one preacher surveyed in this town agreed they could pray without mentioning a specific deity. Would that be a compromise? "

Yes, but not good enough. For example, pagans don't typically pray to a deity at all. Atheists certainly don't pray to a deity, since they don't believe one exists. The issue is not that a specific deity is mentioned, it's that our government is respecting a religion, by allowing a representative to come and pray at the government meeting.

dogbark said
"It would not offend me as a free citizen, if these preachers began a prayer "I will now pray," and conclude "I ask in (God's) name."...
...let the preachers begin 'I will now pray...' "

While I agree it would be better if the religious representative used the words "I will no pray", the fact is the meeting stops. The council stands up and bows their head, and they "

dogs4you wrote on Aug 6, 2009 4:14 PM:

" LodiFreeThinker, you bring up a good point by saying, that according to the Christian Bible the earth is about 6000 years old, not so. Fossil proof tells us that the dinosaurs roamed the earth 200 million years ago, a seperation of 170 million years. I like what living proof tells me, in a fossil form that is. To say the dinosaurs didn`t exist is like saying the Holocaust didn`t happen, also the Bible cannot explain the caveman, which most certainly existed. "

lodimaestro wrote on Aug 6, 2009 4:12 PM:

" It has been said here eloquently but I'll say it again: prayer has no place at such public meetings. When a minister gets up and announces, "Let us pray," it infuriates and offends me that a government body would imply everyone in the audience is a Christian or a believer in a higher power. Make no mistake, such nonsense at the beginning of these council meetings endorses such a belief, whether it is implicit or overt. Want to pray? Go to church. Want a constant affirmation of your religious beliefs? Look into your own hearts and stop demanding it from public meetings. "

iambic grape stomp wrote on Aug 6, 2009 4:12 PM:

" If there must be something to kick off these meetings, why not a moment of silence for the men and women serving in Iraq & Afghanistan instead of deities? Could it work? "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 6, 2009 3:42 PM:

" stucknlodi, Im not sure what dinosaurs have to do with the discussion. But I'll bite....

Fossil evidence suggests dinosaurs lived on the earth over 200 million years ago, and continued to do so until they went extinct about 65 million years ago.

The Christian Bible is believed by religious scholars to have been written about 3000 years ago. It also suggests that the earth was created 6000 years ago.

So if you believe the first part, about being written 3000 years ago.. then NO, dinosaurs didn't exist during that period.

If you believe the second part, about the earth only being 6000 years old, then you may as well just pretend dinosaurs didn't ever exist, because there is no way they were here that recently without there being massive evidence that showed it. "

shockedinlodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 3:23 PM:

" stucknlodi - The word ‘dinosaur’ was not invented until the mid 1800's. The King James Bible was translated into English in 1611, so we would not expect to find the word ‘dinosaur.’
Three words may be synonymous, argue some Christians, for the huge lizards: “tanniyn,” “behemoth,” and “leviathan.” The most widely used example is “behemoth,” which is found in Job.
Some have used direct biblical text to try and back up their analysis. An example is that these large creatures have “tails like cedar trees” in the Bible, which many dispute must be dinosaurs.

So to answer your question "Can someone tell me if the dinosaur was alive during Biblical time period?" I don’t think this is a yes or no question. "

dogbark wrote on Aug 6, 2009 3:20 PM:

" LodiFreeThinker wrote "A prayer at the city council meetings, is not neutral. Whether or not the name 'Jesus' is involved, praying to a god is tacit government acknowledgment of theistic belief. "
Right to the point! Now all but one preacher surveyed in this town agreed they could pray without mentioning a specific deity. Would that be a compromise? It would not offend me as a free citizen, if these preachers began a prayer "I will now pray," and conclude "I ask in (God's) name."
That shows it is THEIR personal belief as an invited guest. But when they begin "Let US pray.." or end with "WE ask in (God's) name..." they cross the line beyond 'tacit' acknowledgement.
That is not appropriate. What do you think the Wiscn group would think if this compromise was proposed; let the preachers begin 'I will now pray...' "

stucknlodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 3:11 PM:

" Can someone tell me if the dinosaur was alive during Biblical time period?????? To me that is more important than saying prayer at a CC meeting. "

dogbark wrote on Aug 6, 2009 3:07 PM:

" Couldn't we just go back to the calm quiet days of Christians leaving photos of aborted fetuses on our doorsteps? "

shockedinlodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 3:01 PM:

" 4AStrongLodi - "And, everyone I spoke to on the Separation Church/State side was from Lodi."

This is not true. David asked people in from other cities as well. I saw the websites talking about carpooling. Please don't act like one side had citizen's from Lodi while the other only asked Lodi citizen's to come. That was my issue with the whole circus. I think we the people of Lodi can figure this out all by ourselves and we do not need outside interest groups coming in and telling us what to do or not to do. I just hope that the downtown made some money off all the clowns last night. "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:57 PM:

" ccinlodi wrote - "How dare the Freedom from Religion Foundation presume to think for me and all aetheists and not even ask us if we felt the need for their intervention??"

Yes, how dare they insist on upholding the establishment clause of The U.S. Constitution.

Also, there is only one E in Atheist. "

sooziesdad wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:52 PM:

" Except for a couple of goofy kids yelling Jesus Jesus every couple of seconds (like that really is going to make someone throw themselves down on the ground and convert), this was a very civil affair and I'm proud that both sides exhibted tact and decorum.

Feelings run high on this issue thus the need to look at the policy and see if it still fits. I believe it does. No one is saying that someone cannot pray. Let's see if we can do it with mutual respect and without trying to do it in such a way that it insults other religions.

Without a doubt I am absolutely convinced that if a member of the Muslim community started the meeting with a prayer to Allah and ending with a tribute to Muhammed, all hell would break lose. We are a religious, not necessarily a Christian, nation made up of a number of faiths. Is the expectation that we start lining up everyone from Atheists to Evangelical Christians so they all can have their say to start what is essentially a business meeting? "

LodiFreeThinker wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:50 PM:

" Jenn H said - "...Lodi is NOT a "Christian" town. It is an AMERICAN town"

I couldn't agree more. Our local government should be setting an example by celebrating our diversity and remaining neutral in matters of theology.

A prayer at the city council meetings, is not neutral. Whether or not the name 'Jesus' is involved, praying to a god is tacit government acknowledgment of theistic belief. "

ccinlodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:36 PM:

" what craziness! other than the few hot topics that the council discusses every few months.( thank you Walmart) .. most citizens do not attend the city council meetings unless they have business before the council....how can so many people be offended or not be offended if a guest minister invokes or does not invoke the name of Jesus at meetings they do not attend?? where is the logic in being offended? Be offended more by those out of state idiots that threaten to bully us with lawsuits... I am an aetheist, and I live in this town.. no one asked me if I wanted to sue my city council because they say prayers to a god I don't believe in... now I am offended on behalf of all registered voting aetheists in Lodi (Canadian voting rights doesn't count..).... How dare the Freedom from Religion Foundation presume to think for me and all aetheists and not even ask us if we felt the need for their intervention?? hmmmm. maybe I can sue them on behalf of all aetheistic Lodians... "

uncle stinky wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:23 PM:

" phuca nutt mutna wll ifcaga gabba gabba hey we accect you one of us tinka kolta retuler inta klok. frating hela hela niter, writing in tounges "

Contrapasso wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:17 PM:

" And to those who say the founding fathers are "spinning in their graves": Just who wrote the Declaration of Independence? I think it was the founding fathers! It starts out like this:
"When, in the course of human events, it becomes necessary for one people to dissolve the political bonds which have connected them with another, and to assume among the powers of the earth, the separate and equal station to which the laws of nature and of nature's God entitle them, a decent respect to the opinions of mankind requires that they should declare the causes which impel them to the separation."

It continues:
"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness."

It concludes like this:
"with a firm reliance on the protection of Divine Providence, we mutually pledge to each other our lives, our fortunes and our sacred honor." "

Contrapasso wrote on Aug 6, 2009 2:10 PM:

" The constitution of the United States does not prohibit religious expression in a public forum:

Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

Sorry folks, but being offended by other people's speech is not a constitutional right. Get over it. "

commonsense1 wrote on Aug 6, 2009 1:55 PM:

" Kind of wierd. I pray every night before bedtime and consider myself religous. However, I'm having a problem with people having a need for prayer before a city council meeting. Why is a moment of silence objectionable to anyone? I don't have a problem with people of other faiths that may object, but I don't want to be bunched up with agnostics and atheists. Also, I see no need to parade your children up and down the sidewalks. That is objectionable and sickening. "

momintum wrote on Aug 6, 2009 1:49 PM:

" Certainly it is by now most obvious that particular recognition or the non-recognition of a favorite god can be detrimental to peace and harmony among the local or even national segments of society in general and more specifically toward the religiously inclined. Throughout civilization the attributes of this or that god has been forced upon the populace for thousands of years. As these were and are replaced by others and hopefully in the very near future by reason and logic, please allow them to fade into the annals of Ancient History without more turmoil than absolutely is unavoidable. To respect the citizenry it should be clear that to avoid references to any deity is the more practical and sensible approach from local, state, or national government. I urge you to consider the ramifications of a decision that adds to the turbulence of religious prejudice. "

dogs4you wrote on Aug 6, 2009 1:22 PM:

" Barnum and Bailey would have been proud of last night`s fiasco, while there might not have been any wild animals, there was most certainly enough clowns, and I thought I saw Elvis. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 6, 2009 1:05 PM:

" Why were some people "speaking in tongues"??? "

Lodian wrote on Aug 6, 2009 12:57 PM:

" Cogito wrote on Aug 6, 2009 7:45 AM:

" Look at the postures and expressions of the men in the photos. Who looks angry, and who looks peaceful and reasoned? I think it speaks volumes for the mindset on each side of the issue. "


I think you need to take a look at the slideshow photos. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 6, 2009 12:55 PM:

" Jenn H (Aug 6 @ 7:28am): Great comments. "

Bob Loblaw wrote on Aug 6, 2009 12:09 PM:

" T & C wrote: " You "Out of town" Whiner's have had your 15 minutes of "Fame"! Will you please LEAVE Lodi Now! "

Jdizzle wrote: "Now why don't you organized out of town protesters go home..."

Xenophobia is why Lodi remains a backward, incestuous town that only makes the news when something embarrassing happens. Shameful. "

4AStrongLodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 11:54 AM:

" T & C and others - I live in Lodi and am a Lodi High grad, so I feel I have every right to express my opinion. I thought this country was founded on Freedom? But, you want anyone who doesn't agree to move out of town? Vyer bbright thinking there, imbecile (you'll have to look it up in the dictionary).

And, everyone I spoke to on the Separation Church/State side was from Lodi. The out-of-towners were the two pastors leading the Jesus Freaks' rally: one was from Colorado and another was from another part of the State. Many of their protestors were from the Sacramento-area.

I don't know who the nut was who was all over the news, but I know he was there early for that display and he was not part of our rally. He was probably some poser who wanted to get on TV. "

T & C wrote on Aug 6, 2009 11:45 AM:

" You "Out of town" Whiner's have had your 15 minutes of "Fame"! Will you please LEAVE Lodi Now! "

Darwinlives wrote on Aug 6, 2009 10:48 AM:

" Why do people keep thinking this was organized by "out of towners"? Diskin is local and a good guy. And, unfortunately for you hyper-Christians, he is correct. There should be no prayer before the meetings. Let the individual council members pray at home. They need to get down to business and get things done. If they need a prayer to do their business, they should get off the council. When God starts printing money to pay the bills, then the council can pray. "

mp wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:56 AM:

" I believe all people of all faiths should be allowed to offer prayer at city council meeting. Including Mr. Diskin. "

mp wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:54 AM:

" Oh - that comment was to you Jenn H. "

mp wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:53 AM:

" Glad you are not making the decisions. "

Jdizzle wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:40 AM:

" I AM NOT A CHRISTIAN!! and yet I do not mind saying a PRAYER.. Whether I believe or do not believe in Jesus, does not affect my life if the City Council says a prayer. You protesters against the prayer really need to lighten up and live your lives. Get a job, do some good or just stay home and take care of yourself and your families.
For those who commented on there shame and embarrassment that the city would say a prayer MOVE... The council has said a prayer for decades... Where were the protesters then?
As an immigrant to this country I understand the country was founded on Christian values. I appreciate the FREEDOMS given to me by this country. I wish the people born and raised in this country would do the same.

Now why don't you organized out of town protesters go home...

I have to go to work... "

Cogito wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:39 AM:

" 4AStrongLodi, what about the Neo-Nazi looking leftist guy, who reportedly liked to go around getting in the Christians faces? I guess he was cool with you since he was picking on the "Jesus freaks". "

4AStrongLodi wrote on Aug 6, 2009 9:31 AM:

" Went to the rally; great turnout for both sides and a peaceful gathering. There were a few of the "Jesus Freaks" who didn't behave in a very Christian-like manner, but on the whole, everyone was well-behaved.

It was particularly entertaining when the two pastors started speaking in tongues. I was pretty sure Ashton Kutcher was going to jump out from behind a bush and yell "You've been punked!" "

wtf wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:51 AM:

" Perhaps those in Lodi's Christian community should listen to the sheperds of their flock...it seems that the pastors and other clergy aren't as excited about this blown up situation as some out-of-towners looking for some face time on TV.

Fact is, I heard Rev. Kimber's "prayer" before the council meeting last night on the news. It was PERFECT! "

wtf wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:49 AM:

" Senior pastor Tim Stevenson of Horizon Community Church in Galt said, "God's pretty big. I don't think he needs us to defend his name."

He wishes the energy spent by both groups at the rally could go toward bigger problems facing Lodi and the world, "There are too many things around the world that God told us to go out and do. We got our priorities in the wrong place." "

wtf wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:49 AM:

" Rev. Alan Kimber said he...believes the current policy of non-sectarian and non-denominational prayers is good, if it is adhered to.

He also said many of the clergy he talked with did not attend the rally because it was organized by a group outside of Lodi with an extreme view.

"I think the clergy have a deep sense of commitment to each other and the city," Kimber said. "

leah wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:33 AM:

" Once again, the comments from the religious people prove they just do not get it. They think it's about taking away their rights and it does not have anything to do with that. They wave their signs saying, "Jesus said 'ask in MY name'", etc... well, that's all fine and good, but if you don't believe in Jesus, then it doesn't matter what he said. Would they care what Buddah said? No, because they don't believe in Buddah. Get it through your thick skulls people, please. This is definietly a waste of time and energy. I'm done with this subject and all the ignorance and hate that surrounds it. "

yardcat wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:26 AM:

" Thanks to Jenn for her comments. How would the christians react if someone on the CC decided that Lodi was not just christian but Catholic and started the meeting with a mass?
If a large company had its employees start their day out with a reading from the Koran, they would be stopped in their tracks.
Religion does not belong in government, period. "

davidd wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:15 AM:

" Thanks again to everyone who came out.

I hope that those who are interested in a moment of silence, or separation, will join Lodi United.

Please find us on Facebook (search for "Lodi United") or visit www.LodiUnited.org. "

pooreastside wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:10 AM:

" What in the heck are these groups of out of towners doing representing us anyway. Weiner, the name says it all. Eddie Lopez makes good sense. You need to support what you believe in before it is taken away, like everything else no one stand up for. I'm not a Bible toting Christian, but I'm with Virginia Alejo. Minden, this isn't Canada and you aren't even a US citizen. Canada doesn't count. Keep In God we Trust and Prayer as two of our rights. "

T & C wrote on Aug 6, 2009 8:07 AM:

" This could get ugly!!!! Where are the Police? I will pray for those who are against prayer. "

Cogito wrote on Aug 6, 2009 7:45 AM:

" Look at the postures and expressions of the men in the photos. Who looks angry, and who looks peaceful and reasoned? I think it speaks volumes for the mindset on each side of the issue. "

realist wrote on Aug 6, 2009 7:36 AM:

" "This country was made becuase of our religion"? Alejo is ignorant. This country was made so that everyone could have freedom of religion. Not so that everyone had to believe the same thing. "

Jenn H wrote on Aug 6, 2009 7:28 AM:

" Once again I am ashamed of and find myself apologizing for the fact that I grew up and still reside in Lodi. This isn't rocket science. It isn't even worthy of debate. Prayers to specific, named deities have no business in public forums and/or government. That's all there is to it. People of all faiths can pray silently any time, anywhere. Or out loud in their houses of worship or religious gatherings. But NOT before the City Council meetings. Contrary to what our own mayor said (another moment worthy of shame and apologies), Lodi is NOT a "Christian" town. It is an AMERICAN town. And our forefathers are spinning in their graves over this ridiculous controversy. They founded this country to eliminate and escape this kind of sheer lunacy. To those Christians marching around downtown last night, know this: You do NOT represent me. You embarrass me -- and the name of our Savior. "

jbhiker wrote on Aug 6, 2009 6:43 AM:

" California. The land of Fruits and Nuts! "

Curveball wrote on Aug 6, 2009 5:36 AM:

" Using Canada as an example,,,,,,,,,hmmm,,,makes you stop and think. "

Comments on this story are now closed.