Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Indexes

February 9th, 2010
February 8th, 2010
February 6th, 2010
February 5th, 2010
February 4th, 2010
February 3rd, 2010
February 2nd, 2010
ADVERTISEMENT

Messy Lodi house leads to parents' arrest

Children placed in protective custody

By Layla Bohm
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Friday, July 31, 2009 5:59 AM PDT

Two Lodi parents are accused of having such a messy house that police arrested them and took their two young boys into protective custody.

Alisha Blake, 28, and Rick Munn, 34, are expected to appear in court today, two days after their Wednesday arrest.

Prosecutors had not yet filed formal charges Thursday against the two, who were being held in jail on suspicion of child cruelty. Blake could also face a charge of violating terms of her probation for a February petty theft conviction at a Stockton Mervyn's store.

Lodi police said the couple's Park Street home was so filled with clothing and garbage piles that they could barely walk through, and one bedroom door wouldn't open due to the accumulation.

A strong smell of garbage wafted out the partially open kitchen window Thursday, near the adjacent front door that held a sign reading, "Bless Our Home."

A city code enforcement officer had posted a notice on the door that the house has substandard living conditions and must be vacated within five days. The piles of belongings and garbage made it an immediate risk to the residents' safety, said Supervising Community Improvement Officer Jamie Aldred.

"Most people who are in this kind of situation don't even realize they would be encapsulated in their own home if there were to be a fire," she said.

Two boys in the home, ages 2 and 4, appeared to be healthy, Sgt. Fernando Martinez said. However, the home's condition was bad enough to warrant calling Child Protective Services, he said.

Martinez estimated that police arrest the parents in about one out of every six such cases involving reports of child cruelty or neglect. In the rest, officers refer the matter to prosecutors, who decide whether to pursue criminal charges.

Tuesday's incident started around 8 a.m., when police dispatchers received a 9-1-1 call that was disconnected. As they typically do, dispatchers then sent an officer to the home to check on the occupants.

When police arrived in the neighborhood just west of Ham Lane, they found "clothing, garbage and property covering the floor and stacked to the ceiling in some places," Martinez said.

In a bedroom where both boys sleep, officers allegedly found clothing and other items stacked five feet high. The garage was filled with stacks of personal belongings reaching seven feet high, Martinez said.

Police said they found old food in the refrigerator.

A neighbor, who declined to give her name, said she'd seen the inside of the home once about a year ago, and saw that it was filled with piles of clothing.

Another neighbor, Marlene Schwedhelm, said the couple had rented the home for perhaps six years and had "cute little kids." Munn used to wave at Schwedhelm as he left for work, but she didn't know them personally and had noticed that the garage was now filled with belongings.

The residents always enter the house through a gate to the back yard, Schwedhelm said, and Wednesday's police visit was the first time she'd seen the front door used.

In the code enforcement order taped to the front door, city officials said the house cannot be occupied until excess items are cleared out, "focusing primarily on the front living room first, and garage as suggested."

The notice ordered that all rooms have three-and-a-half-foot clear walkways in case of emergencies, that clothing cannot be stored next to a hot water heater, that inoperable smoke detectors must be fixed, and that garbage and junk be removed from the back porch.

Owners of the home could not immediately be reached for comment.

Contact reporter Layla Bohm at layla@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

jramagic wrote on Aug 3, 2009 3:01 PM:

" I once had a neighbor like that. They had literally YEARS of food garbage in & out of black plastic sacks piled 8' high around the property. They had a bedroom packed FULL of the same. It was surreal. Rats the size of small cats paraded openly in the daylight in the yard amongst their filthy, neglected playing toddlers. I made it my solemn campaign to run them out...and I finally succeeded. It several took semi-truck sized dumpsters to clean out the place and a full structual rebuild on the house. Backwoods animals they were! "

purelyprecious wrote on Aug 1, 2009 12:27 AM:

" DOGS- why don't you ask her. I doubt she was there, she gets her information from the LPD. I seen the news report on tv and I wonder why the neighbor who was watching the kids didn't call cps or the cops herself. She had a lot of negative things to say but yet she never reported it, shouldnt she also be charged with child negligence? We're all mandated reporters! "

north of the border wrote on Aug 1, 2009 12:23 AM:

" So these people didn't meet your approval. Who are you- or anyone else- to tell someone how they must live in their own property? What is CPS protecting them from? The kids were healthy, so apparently it wasn't unhealthy conditions. Here's hoping that one day someone doesn't disapprove of how you live. "

dogs4you wrote on Jul 31, 2009 7:46 PM:

" Lodian, if kids are raised in this kind of environment, they might believe this is the way it is supposed to be and raise their family in the same manner, since they don`t know any better.

Purely, yes you are putting the reporter down, Ms. Bohm is well qualified and has written about Michel Morales which I believe qualifies her for this article. To write about it, I believe she was on sight, and it was not made up. And I sure as Hell do not believe her boss told her what to write. Your wrong. "

dogs4you wrote on Jul 31, 2009 5:40 PM:

" North of the Border, from the conditions explaned by the reporter, there is more than enough evidence to remove the kids from their careless mother and father. Their mother was charged with petty theft from Mervyn`s and was on probation. To have a house full of garbage is more than enough reason to put their kids in CPS. The article doesn`t say if drugs were found in the house, though it wouldn`t surprise me. And don`t look now but if Obama has his way, we will all be in a government system. "

purelyprecious wrote on Jul 31, 2009 4:50 PM:

" Lets also put into consideration, that news paper articles make it seem worse than it really is, also the information is hear say. I'm not putting the reporter down, she wrote what she was told. I think this story was out of proportion...thats my opinion. "

NORTH OF THE BORDER wrote on Jul 31, 2009 3:36 PM:

" It's not about whether or not I think it's wrong- my opinion is that it is wrong; however, that's not reason enough to decimate a household, arrest parents and stick kids into a government system. "

Lodian wrote on Jul 31, 2009 3:10 PM:

" Let's just visit this for a moment without attacking me for merely asking the question. "

Lodian wrote on Jul 31, 2009 3:05 PM:

" I wondering, in the eyes of the law, where does a messy house become unacceptable? Yes, piles of stinky garbage crosses the line, but should piles of clothes or a collection of "stuff" result is arrest and the taking of "healthy" children from a mom and dad? "

LodiReaderFromStockton wrote on Jul 31, 2009 2:06 PM:

" I can't believe people don't think this was wrong. They were living in more than a mess of a house. It was filled with trash and things that could be hazardous to the kids. The parents obviously need some kind of help and now hopefully they get it. "

dogs4you wrote on Jul 31, 2009 1:37 PM:

" Lodian, you appearently didn`t read the article in which the reporter states that the house was filled with garbage. What part of living under substandard conditions don`t you understand. If you are or were a mother or father, would you allow your kids live in this squaller. The line is draw when the piles of clothes and garbage are allowed too grow, as they should have never been allowed to accumulate in the first. place. I have no sympathy for the mother and father as they seem to not care for their kids, especially with no food in the fridge. Now they will have to answer the question, what were you thinking, that living like this is OK ? "

Lodian wrote on Jul 31, 2009 1:14 PM:

" This is important to note...

"Two boys in the home, ages 2 and 4, appeared to be healthy, Sgt. Fernando Martinez said." "

Lodian wrote on Jul 31, 2009 1:13 PM:

" I wonder where the line is drawn in some areas here. Piles in the garage and clothes stacked in the bedroom doesn't sound like it warrants a visit from the police or CPS. Is there a written guideline for this sort of thing or is it just by individual opinion by officers and CPS? "

T & C wrote on Jul 31, 2009 12:57 PM:

" Please take those kids! Those parents sound like "winners"! NOT! "

dogs4you wrote on Jul 31, 2009 12:37 PM:

" Remove the kids, bulldoze the house with the worthless mother and father in it. "

north of the border wrote on Jul 31, 2009 12:06 PM:

" At risk of what?
Was this place a dump? Probably. But how do you legislate how messy a house can be or how clean it must be?
Last time I checked, the adults payed the bills- not Lodi PD or CPS.
How do you legislate where the line is drawn without impeding the rights of others? "

Journey wrote on Jul 31, 2009 11:58 AM:

" Look, the children were at risk and the authorities did the right thing in removing them from the home. So let's just cut them some slack, OK? The parents obviously need psychiatric evaluation and some sort of treatment and they weren't going to get it without intervention. "

wtf wrote on Jul 31, 2009 10:29 AM:

" north of the border I have to agree with you. So far, in the various news stories I've read, there's been parents arrested for a messy house; a teacher arrested because he bonked a 17 year old three years ago - meaning she's 20 now - and they've been together for three years with a five month old baby; and yet another pot bust.

With all the budget cuts - including the PD and Sheriff's department, for some reason, I think the priorities would be different; however, the "messy" parents and the teacher will both be a source of revenue for CPS when they're fined for their "crimes" "

north of the border wrote on Jul 31, 2009 10:00 AM:

" Wow. I feel safer already and will sleep well tonight.
I guess this makes up for not catching the real bad guy that had every Lodi PD doing K9 house to house searches on Corbin. "

Mad Dog wrote on Jul 31, 2009 7:58 AM:

" The maid must be on vacation this week. "

Comments on this story are now closed.