Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Indexes

November 2nd, 2009
November 6th, 2009
November 5th, 2009
November 4th, 2009
November 3rd, 2009
November 2nd, 2009
October 31st, 2009
October 30th, 2009
ADVERTISEMENT
Frank Rocha, right, a supporter of bullfighting, reacts about the two men arrested during Thornton's Friday night bullfight, in front of the Lodi courthouse where the men were arraigned Tuesday. Also pictured is Sam Tunnell, of Acampo. (Brian Feulner/News-Sentinel)

Thornton bullfight arrestees charged with misdemeanors

Supporters gather at the courthouse

By Layla Bohm
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:20 AM PDT

Some 50 supporters gathered in Lodi court Tuesday, where two men were arraigned on charges related to a ruckus at a weekend bullfight in Thornton.

The polite crowd cheered afterward outside the courthouse, when defense attorney Randy Thomas explained that the men are only facing misdemeanors and would be released from jail Tuesday evening.


Darren Nunes

Cesar Rocha, 38, and Darren Nunes, 23, pleaded not guilty to one misdemeanor each of assault on an officer, and Rocha is also charged with resisting arrest.

Both were arrested Friday night after a Southern California-based animal rights investigator showed up at the bullfight in Thornton, which was part of a weekend-long Portuguese festival.

Neither man has a criminal record, Thomas told Judge David Warner, and he began making a pitch for their release from custody when the judge interrupted. Warner noted that the charges are misdemeanors, then asked a prosecutor if his office opposed a release.

The prosecutor did not request bail, and Warner ordered the men released on their promise to appear at future court dates. He scheduled a June 15 court date.


Cesar Rocha

Four extra deputies, including a sergeant, were summoned to the court building when bailiffs saw the crowd outside. However, their concern was not with the supporters, but with the possibility of a confrontation if animal-rights activists appeared. That did not happen, and the five-minute arraignment was uneventful.

Supporters outside court insisted that bulls are not injured in the fights, for which organizers get permits and have medics and deputies on scene.

"There is no blood, all the permits are in place; it's not some underground thing like a cockfight," said Acampo resident Sam Tunnell, who has attended many bullfights in Thornton, including Friday's.

He and other witnesses said the animal officer jumped a fence, rather than paying admission, and ran into the arena. There Nunes physically confronted him.

Nunes, of Los Banos, works as a sales distributor and previously served in Iraq and Afghanistan with the military, Thomas said.


Thornton's bullfighting rink lies off North Sacramento Road, behind the Thornton Community Center, Thornton Portuguese Hall and Mater Ecclesiae Catholic Church. (Ross Farrow/News-Sentinel)

Deputies were still sorting out the incident and Rocha was involved in a verbal dispute with them at the back of the arena, Tunnell said.

"Then a deputy comes running up from behind and tackles (Rocha). (Rocha) is blindsided, so he turns to fight back and has no idea that it's a cop," Tunnell said.

Tunnell was upset at the deputy's actions, and was frustrated when he asked for their badge numbers and names but was refused.

"I don't even know (Rocha). I've never met him in my life, but that's why I came here today," said Tunnell, noting good-naturedly that he was one of the few non-Portuguese people in the crowd. "You can't treat someone like that; we have rights in this country and the deputies can't get away with that."

The Sheriff's Office previously said in a press release that a deputy was injured during that confrontation. The injury was apparently not serious enough to warrant a felony charge.

Rocha owns a dairy and was never involved in the original incident with the animal officer in the arena, Thomas said.

As for the bullfight, numerous supporters said outside court that the bulls are not injured. Bullfights started in Thornton in 1971 and have been uneventful, said Joe Goncalves of Lodi, who organized Friday's bullfight.

For Stockton resident Sev Magina, the bullfights have been fun events he has attended since 1973, and he enjoys taking his two children to the festivals.

Bulls are raised in open pastures, then run once in the bullfight and retired until they go to a slaughterhouse, Magina said.

"You can legally hunt and kill an animal. You can catch a fish and leave a hook in its mouth for an hour," he said, asking why those practices don't come under more scrutiny.

Contact reporter Layla Bohm at layla@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

Galtguy wrote on Jun 4, 2009 9:26 AM:

" For those of you interested in letting these ACI folks know how you feel here are some e-mail addy's for them;

Jane@JaneGarrison.com
Info@ACInvestigations.org

Take a minute and let them know you don't appreciate their tactics. I'll post more info as I get it. "

dogs4you wrote on Jun 3, 2009 2:00 PM:

" Looks like there might have been a little to much action for PETA to handle. There is a bloodless bull fight ring on Escalon-Bellota Rd. The idea is for the contestent to pull the bulls tail 5 times, the cowboy wins a and the bull trots off a field, and to show the their appreciation, the bull ends up at In and Out Burger. I have a feeling that if a licence is needed, you might have seen the last of the "bull fights". Maybe even better, put up a cage and a couple of fighters in it, nobody seems to care how much blood flows from a human, or cares. Blood and booze an unbeatable combination. "

Gator wrote on Jun 3, 2009 1:04 PM:

" 35lodian, a little Dust~off will fix your Caps-lock!!! "

redonkulous wrote on Jun 3, 2009 9:16 AM:

" I agree! I wonder if the people that attended the event could serve ACI with a class action lawsuit for dirupting the event and potentially causing bodily harm, not to mention much undue stress. Not sure if you were present, but a few years ago a bull got loose from the corrals and made it's way through the crowd hurting several people. Those wack-job, tree hugging people would do something like that and this guy certainly fit the bill! "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2009 9:05 AM:

" Redonkulous, that's the person I'm referring to, the ACI guy, he should be charged. "

35lodian wrote on Jun 3, 2009 8:33 AM:

" I BEEN GOING TO BULL FIGHTS FOR MANY YEARS AND I HAVN'T SEEN OR HEARD OF ANY TROUBLE FROM THE EVENT. IF THERE WAS ANYTHING BEING DONE ILLEGALLY THEN WHY DON'T THE DEPUTIES OUTSIDE PATROLLING THE EVENT STOP IT. AS FAR AS FOR THE DEPUTY THAT TACKLED ROCHA HE SHOULDN'T TAKE THE LAW INTO HIS OWN HANDS. HE NEEDS TO BE MORE TRAINED TO EVENTS LIKE THIS TO HANDLE THE SITUTION BETTER.. "

ap wrote on Jun 3, 2009 8:28 AM:

" This was the right outcome. This guy dressed in street clothes runs into the ring, who's to say he wasn't some crazy trying to hurt someone. I think it was self defense. I think that none of these charges should have ever happened. Cop or not you can't blindside someone and think they are not going to fight back. These are just good citizens doing nothing wrong. "

redonkulous wrote on Jun 3, 2009 7:57 AM:

" Cogito if anyone should be charged with inciting a riot it should be that idiot who caused this in the first place. What did he think that we would just hand him what he wanted and blow kisses at him as he drove off into the sunset. Hopefully Thomas decides to pursue it a little further. "

redonkulous wrote on Jun 3, 2009 7:55 AM:

" This outcome was agreeable with me and I am glad to see that the LNS printed more of what happened instead of glorifying what the law enforcement and ACI did. It's finally printed that the guy entered illegally, didn't posses a warrent to obtain the evidence he wanted and that a police officer tackeled Rocha from behind which led to the confrontation and then the charges. It's good to see that supporters showed up and were calm and collective during the outcome. I'm looking forward to the next bullfight...hopefully I will see many of you there. "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2009 7:49 AM:

" Where are the charges for inciting a riot against the guy who jumped into the ring? Isn't he the one who started this entire, unnecessary mess? "

Comments on this story are now closed.