Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Indexes

February 9th, 2010
February 8th, 2010
February 6th, 2010
February 5th, 2010
February 4th, 2010
February 3rd, 2010
February 2nd, 2010
ADVERTISEMENT
After 28 years in Lodi, Plummer Automall will be closing its doors Wednesday. (Brian Feulner/News-Sentinel)

Longtime Lodi auto dealership Plummer Automall to close Wednesday

By Andrew Adams
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Tuesday, February 24, 2009 6:47 AM PST

Plummer Automall will close its doors this week, making it the second major auto dealer in Lodi to succumb to the souring economy and putting 59 people out of work.

On Monday, employees were driving the remaining Cadillac, GMC, Pontiac and Buick vehicles off the main lot to a secured area behind the dealership located on Kettleman Drive east of Highway 99.

By late afternoon, the expansive lot was empty save for one used Cadillac El Dorado.


Dennis Plummer

In a statement released Monday, the dealership's president, Dennis Plummer, said "it is with deep regret" that the business would close, "bringing to an end a proud legacy of serving the Lodi and Stockton communities for nearly 30 years."

"This was not an easy decision for the management of our company and one that it went to great lengths to try and avoid," Plummer said. He added that management tried to re-negotiate its commitments with the General Motors Acceptance Corporation and Farmers and Merchants Bank but ultimately was unsuccessful.

He noted that in 2008 the company generated $975,000 in sales tax revenue for the city of Lodi and San Joaquin County.

"I want to take this very sad time to thank the Lodi community for your business and support for the last 28 years," Plummer said. "It was our honor to serve this fabulous community and the people within it."


After 28 years in Lodi, Plummer Automall will be closing its doors Wednesday. (Brian Feulner/News-Sentinel)

Plummer's closure follows that of Geweke Chrysler Jeep Dodge, which ceased operations earlier this month.

As with Geweke, rumors of Plummer's demise had been circulating throughout the city for weeks prior to the dealership's announcement.

The auto industry has been one of the hardest hit sectors of the current economic downturn, and the industry's struggles can be seen as local dealerships close their doors.

Last year, new car sales in California fell 23 percent, a considerably larger drop than the nation as a whole, where sales of cars and light trucks declined 18 percent. At the same time, with General Motors, Ford, Chrysler and even Toyota in bad financial shape, dealers are getting squeezed from their manufacturers to offer incentives that in crease sales volume but cut profits even further.

That has led to dealership failures, with 137 new car dealers going out of business last year and another 22 so far in 2009, said Peter Welch, president of the California New Car Dealers Association. The impact on local tax collection of those closures can be huge, with some municipalities depending on car sales for as much as one-third of their revenue.

The Los Angeles Times contributed to this report.

Contact City Editor Andrew Adams at andrewa@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

LodiJoe wrote on Mar 2, 2009 2:53 PM:

" MAINFRAME, a lot of people are realizing the true cost of playing the "Affluent" game on borrowed money. Sooner or later it will bite you in the butt. The days of living within our means and not lusting after possessions we cannot afford are back. I am a "boomer" guy, we had ONE tv, ONE car and there were 7 in our family. We did just fine in a modest 3 bdrm 1 bath house. "

Lodian wrote on Mar 2, 2009 10:26 AM:

" Mainframe: You were very wise not to mortgage your house for extra toys. So many people took out a second mortgage to finance a high end new car, boat or vacation. Those days are over and many of those folks left their foreclosed homes behind as well as their good credit, which is now in the tank. "

Mainframe wrote on Feb 28, 2009 8:31 PM:

" LodiJoe: I'm sure glad I never fell into that trap. I never got that second on my house like a lot of other people did. "

LodiJoe wrote on Feb 28, 2009 5:41 AM:

" No wonder the rest of the world thinks Americans are crazy. We buy $75K Cadillac Escalades, put expensive gasoline in them and drive them a mile to sit in them, idling, and waiting in line in a drive through to pay $8 for a cup of "coffee". All on borrowed money. "

Gator wrote on Feb 26, 2009 5:57 PM:

" From the first Oil embargo till now the US went through seven administrations with out
a workable energy policy. And Detroit kept on building Gas hogs bigger and better. Madison avenue ran the add campaign that made everyone want the big SUV, Pickups
you know the drill!! Then the nasty Saudis and their ilk had the gall to run the price of
Fuel up through the roof and they are at it again now!! What the H*** its their oil, right? 4.50 a gallon was the rock that started the financial land slide.. To quote the
Reverend J Wright, the Chickens has come home to roost. "

justlookin wrote on Feb 25, 2009 1:45 PM:

" heard that geweke rv center moved its service dept to geweke auto body & paint.that is wonderful news for rv owners. i am please. "

danielh wrote on Feb 25, 2009 1:01 AM:

" Nobody is prosecuting these bankers.

I wonder if these congressional "bailouts" are nothing other than reward programs for these prolific bankers. "

danielh wrote on Feb 25, 2009 12:59 AM:

" The dropping economy is due in a major part to banking fraud.

We were given fair notice on CNN.

On the average, bankers took the promissory notes from home buyers, and put them into the photocopy machine, onto the bank's stationary, thereby creating a duplicate note, ON THE AVERAGE 30 TIMES PER NOTE!

Some promissory notes were copied as much as 50 times! 30 times is the average.

Strict accounting procedures apply only to the original note, not the copies.

China realizes they are holding fraudulent notes, and they are calling these promissory notes for payment, and the banks are liable because the copies are on their stationary.

Since the notes are copies, the banks don't have the money, and this is causing the banks to crash. "

SJUNE74 wrote on Feb 24, 2009 9:58 PM:

" Yes it is sad to hear both dealers out of business/services is what makes you keep coming back to them/Friendly employees gives you a smile & greetings/
I got my first Ford Mustang @ Giewke 1985/ "

Cogito wrote on Feb 24, 2009 8:30 PM:

" i agree with your sentiments completely Sam. Dennis had a good run here. Everyone who worked for him got a paycheck at the end of the day. That fulfilled all his obligations as an employer to his employees. enjoy your retirement sir, well done. "

sam wrote on Feb 24, 2009 7:39 PM:

" Dogs, GMAC failings is sad... actually in my eye, pathetic.

Sure, it would be great for Dennis to go out on top, but that is not going to happen. So I say, Dennis, great job and enjoy your retirement. "

dogs4you wrote on Feb 24, 2009 7:30 PM:

" Sam even though Dennis Plummer is going to retire, to have the rug pulled out from under him by GMAC is a cold way to go. I would think he would like to go out on his own terms rather than see his dealership striped of the cars and now looks like an empty parking lot, which it now is, along with all the sales tax that Lodi desperately needs. Sad. "

Observer wrote on Feb 24, 2009 7:20 PM:

" Dennis sold the Nevada dealership about two years ago. "

sam wrote on Feb 24, 2009 6:56 PM:

" Plummer's dealership is no longer profitable and Dennis wants to retire. Go for it Dennis.

You had a great run and how lucky you are to be able to retire with a vacation home in Pebble Beach. Well done, Dennis. "

Cogito wrote on Feb 24, 2009 6:40 PM:

" Jason J, when did the Bush administration start running GM? "

Cogito wrote on Feb 24, 2009 6:38 PM:

" Whoanellie, why would he sell an asset like that? That would be like throwing a bucket of water to a drowning person. Good for him that he has a house in Pebble Beach. "

dogs4you wrote on Feb 24, 2009 5:08 PM:

" The Truth--- or lack of it states that SWM would put them out of business. Last I heard SWM didn`t sell cars. Lots of talk concerning Costco coming to Lodi, with the economy the way it is, lucky to get a hot dog vendor.

Jason J concerning the first 6 years of the Bush administration, the Dow was over 14,000, houses were being built and the ecomomy was good. Not untill the last 2 years when the Democrats got hold of Congress did the economy start in a downward sprial. Now with Obama running the show, only time will tell how he will be tested, hopefully he will find a spine and treat those little runts that run N. Korea and Iran the same way Mr. Bush did and doesn`t give up the ranch with allot of talk that is going nowhere. Four years worth of Obama and this country will be ready for another Republican President. "

Whoa Nellie! wrote on Feb 24, 2009 5:08 PM:

" Wowerzz, good point about the Nevada dealership. And does Plummer own that dealership by himself or also a partnership with Tiem (spelling?)??

I guess Dennis never gave the idea of selling his house in Pebble Beach to raise operating cash huh?

Close to $1M in sales tax for Lodi and SJC, I wonder what was Lodi's share? Yikes! More cuts for the firemen! "

the truth wrote on Feb 24, 2009 4:27 PM:

" Hey Jason J - I guess they should have gone to Obama so he could hand them some of my money to stay open. "

Wowerzz wrote on Feb 24, 2009 3:52 PM:

" I wonder if Plummer still owns his Chevrolet/GM dealerships in Nevada...?...and does F&M own the lot now???....how about F&M caddy,buick,pontiac & GMC...just needed a few sign changes and some Lodians would still have a job.. "

prospectmotorsfan wrote on Feb 24, 2009 3:48 PM:

" It is a shame to see good long-time dealers such as Plummer have to close due to losing financing. GMAC froze credit lines of long-time dealer in Jackson, Frank Halvorson's Prospect Motors, Amador Toyota and Amador Motors five days before Christmas, putting 80 people out of work and leaving us GM, Toyota and Dodge owners in the lurch for service. At least Lodians can now go to Sanborn Chevrolet for warranty service. Those of us in Amador County now have no other option other than to travel to the valley for service. GMAC is doing GM's dirty work for them by freezing out dealers, while at the same time take billions of our taxpayer dollars to bail them out of their debts. "

Jason J wrote on Feb 24, 2009 3:38 PM:

" Another sad story..the scares of the Bush adminisration! "

steve wrote on Feb 24, 2009 2:58 PM:

" I have purchased a truck and two cars from them, the employees gave nothing but great service, I think of those who are left without a job, what a sad day for us all. "

the truth wrote on Feb 24, 2009 2:21 PM:

" Google Bodie and you'll see the fate of livable lovable Lodie "

the truth wrote on Feb 24, 2009 2:19 PM:

" Just as well. Super Walmart would have put them out of business anyway! Fight Fight Fight against the big box stores and the taxes they generate. "

wtf wrote on Feb 24, 2009 2:07 PM:

" Inquisitor/patton1....Nope! LOL! "

Inquisitor wrote on Feb 24, 2009 1:58 PM:

" wtf: Shouldn't you be bringing up Ron Paul in this? "

jay dubb wrote on Feb 24, 2009 1:31 PM:

" Come on patton1 - The tax dollars that would be kept in Lodi if Measure W passes will be taken away from the already struggling school district. This story is about the very sad closure of a well respected business in our town. Not about Measure W and how the City Council tried to shove it down our throats without a vote. It will all be over when it is voted down on March 3rd. "

wtf wrote on Feb 24, 2009 12:51 PM:

" I was wondering when someone would bring up Measure W in relation to this.... LOL! "

jqq wrote on Feb 24, 2009 11:30 AM:

" How much tax revenue is Costco expected to generate when it opens its door next to the Blue Shield building?
No nearly as much as Mr. Plummer's business, but some nonetheless. "

patton1 wrote on Feb 24, 2009 11:15 AM:

" We in Lodi have to take a long hard look at our financial picture. Not only are we contracting, we are permantly losing some of our biggest tax providers. Keeping a larger share of property taxes sure would help. Yes on W "

dogs4you wrote on Feb 24, 2009 11:12 AM:

" Hummers and all the other "big" cars didn`t kill the American auto, though they helped, the price of gas did it`s share. When you could fill your tank for $30, who cared what you were driving.

Weezer is right when he said, and I have been saying all along that the UAW did more than it`s share to kill the American automobile business.

I have delt with Plumber for many years and am sadden that his dealership will close. With the loss of over $900,000 in sales tax, SWM looks pretty good now. "

weezer wrote on Feb 24, 2009 9:57 AM:

" Observer, not sure how anyone would be delighted by this news but some people do surprise me.

Journey and edumacation, another factor that killed the American automakers are the absurd deals they made with the unions. "

lynn wrote on Feb 24, 2009 9:52 AM:

" edumacation: I agree with you, however the only reason they built the Hummer, Navigator, Suburban was they were selling them as fast as they could build them. The demand was there and they filled the need. Americans wanted 6,000 pound vehicles for one person to drive to pick up their coffee. Now with the credit crisis and the past spike in fuel cost, they got caught with no other product available and we see where that left them. If your business is too focused in one direction, it can come back to hurt you. "

edumacation wrote on Feb 24, 2009 9:36 AM:

" Journey I agree. American automobile manufacturers knew back in 1972 about the invasion of Japanese, low cost, high quality, economical cars. They had over thirty years to get it right and they gave us the Hummer, Navigator, Suburban as "cars" when they were really trucks...and hundreds of light truck body vehicles so they wouldn't have to worry about concerns like safety or gas mileage. It might be too late to turn back the clock. "

journey wrote on Feb 24, 2009 9:04 AM:

" Nobody will be "delighted" with the demise of this business but it certainly stands to reason in this particular economy. American car makers didn't keep up with the competition -- and my Suburban and Cadillac were replaced with a Mazda and a Honda for purely financial reasons just last year. "

Observer wrote on Feb 24, 2009 7:07 AM:

" Now this is a real tragedy for our community. Not only is this a tremendous financial loss in sales tax revenue for the City of Lodi the loss of local jobs is even more tragic. Some of these employees have been with Plummer since he bought it from Lou Peters 30 years ago. Of course there will be the usual blogging suspects who will find delight in the demise of a successful local business. "

Comments on this story are now closed.