Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Story Tools

Email this story | Print this story

Indexes

December 1st, 2008
November 30th, 2008
November 29th, 2008
November 28th, 2008
November 27th, 2008
November 26th, 2008
November 25th, 2008
November 24th, 2008
ADVERTISEMENT
Elkhorn students peer out from their school bus after school on Monday. Elkhorn may eliminate school bus transportation. (Dan Evans/News-Sentinel)

Lodi Unified may drop bus service to Elkhorn School

By Jennifer Bonnett
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Updated: Tuesday, August 19, 2008 1:02 AM PDT

Only 59 Elkhorn Elementary families were interested in paying a reduced fee for one-way bus service, which means Lodi Unified may eliminate the route altogether.

The district needed 200 families to pay for the service and to break even for the cost of gas and drivers, said Carlos Garcia, the district's transportation director.

It is now up to district officials to decide whether to discontinue the student transportation, which was originally canceled last spring. Using buses received a slight reprieve when parents said they were willing to cover a portion of the district's cost, but not enough signed up.

By Friday, a final decision will be made, to either give parents extra time to pay, set up yet another fee structure or scrap bus service all together. Garcia said that decision would be made by someone above his position, but district administrators could not be reached for comment late Monday afternoon because they were in a closed-session meeting.

At least 200 students' parents had to commit to the reduced cost — the original price tag was $720 for the school year for transportation in both directions — by Aug. 15, although some parents believed their deadline to pay was this Friday.

At the beginning of this school year, district officials asked parents to pay $720 per child for a pay-to-ride bus service. But with no payment plans in place, coming up with the money the first week school started proved to be a burden for families, especially those with more than one child.

If the district does cut the bus service to Elkhorn, it will refund the money to parents who paid the fee.

Parent Shari Burnett organized meetings with parents and district officials after receiving a letter last month warning of the transportation fee. At the end of last school year, the school board approved cutting the service completely.

Since then, some families have pulled out of the school altogether, others have turned to carpooling to get their students to and from the Stockton school. Although it is located in Stockton, it is part of the Lodi Unified School District and students attend from as far away as Acampo and Lockeford.

Elkhorn School is the district's Gifted and Talented Education campus, serving fourth through eighth-graders. It is located on Davis Road, a country road that has proven to be a safety hazard for parents dropping and picking their children up. Putting more on buses would be safer, according to some parents.

After cutting service in half, officials hoped that at least a couple hundred students would need transportation after school since their parents likely work full time and can't take off in the middle of the day. That cost was to only be $236 for the school year. But Burnett suspects the parents have already committed to carpools for both directions, or weren't clear on the final deadline to pay.

"Everyone involved has tried to find a solution," Elkhorn principal Scott McGregor said. "There has been a lot of partnership, and time will tell if (transportation service) happens or not."

Burnett understands budget cuts are sometimes necessary, but said parents last spring were more worried about the entire school being closed than cuts to the bus system. Like other parents, she thought there still might be money from the state to save Elkhorn's buses.

"It would have been helpful, I believe, to have a dialogue from the get-go," she said of the anticipated cuts.

She added that parents could have come up with other options sooner, including carpooling schedules or recommending changes to the current bus stops.

That's exactly what they did. The second day of school, Burnett and a group of parents met with Garcia, the district's transportation director, and came up with their own plan. Basically, they recommended eliminating the furthest rural bus stop in the Tokay Colony area outside of Lockeford and consolidating other stops to create a more direct path to Elkhorn. Basically, the plan reduced mileage and therefore gas costs.

Parents recently received another letter with the new proposed cost to parents, but the district eliminated all morning bus service.

"My concern is there are a lot of families who use the bus on free and reduced lunches," Burnett said. "I'm afraid they don't know that if not enough people pay, that transportation will go away."

McGregor said he believes all parents are aware of the deadlines and he plans to do his best to communicate any possible changes to the current system.

Carlos said if the bus service is canceled altogether, parents would be notified with at least a one-week grace period.

LUSD is not the only local district facing transportation budget cuts. In Galt, parents whose high school students ride the bus are now charged $1 per way, per day.

Elkhorn parent Suzanne Schreiner already paid the $720 fee for this school year with hopes of securing bus service both ways. She is thankful her son, Bryson, is an eighth-grader and has started his last year at Elkhorn.

"Those with more than one child, or a 4th grader, have more to worry about," she said. "For us, we will either try to get in a carpool or have my oldest drop him off on his way to Delta (College). We will make it work."

Contact reporter Jennifer Bonnett at jenniferb@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

Lodian wrote on Aug 26, 2008 2:16 PM:

" It's probably cheaper to call a cab. "

Audi 5000 wrote on Aug 26, 2008 8:47 AM:

" . . . or to exclusively bus one child who got a transfer to a school across town because their neighborhood school is under performing. "

Audi 5000 wrote on Aug 25, 2008 11:57 AM:

" Yet there is always money to use an entire bus to exclusively transport one overflowed student across town to another school. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 24, 2008 11:26 PM:

" Robb: I can't see any reason to keep Elkhorn open with what they offer the kids right now. "

Robb wrote on Aug 24, 2008 4:02 PM:

" With any luck, the next step may be to close Elkhorn, I have had to take 2 of my children from that campus... "

Lodian wrote on Aug 23, 2008 10:51 AM:

" Actually, I believe that the parents should bus their own children to Elkhorn, as it is a choice to have their student attend this school. Just like an intra-district transfer, coming from their home school area, transportation needs to be provided by the students family. Ideally, it would be nice to provide all of these services, but it's obvious that the funds cannot support such extras. "

advocateforgifted wrote on Aug 20, 2008 5:52 PM:

" It is amazing to read the negativity, prejudice and hateful comments from a group of you who have your own personal axes to grind. If we were talking about athletes who excel (like Olympic athletes) there would be nothing but positive comments. But let the topic drift to children who are intellectually precocious and capable, who have high learning goals, who strive to get good grades at school, and there is nothing but criticism and mud-slinging. We are talking about children's access to a school fit for their curious and creative minds. What is it about that topic that makes some of you revert to adolescent name-calling and childish behavior? "

samiam wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:02 PM:

" READ WHAT ELKHORN ALUMNI SAY ON MYSPACE. So, if you are clever, you can find an Elkhorn alumni group on Myspace. Most members of this group range from 16 to 23 years of age. They can post things about their experiences at Elkhorn. Based on what they post, Elkhorn is heck on earth. Very few had good things to post. Most had a miserable experience at the school. "

Goodhouse wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:21 PM:

" To nocoen....You will sure take a lot of "heat" over your comment about the seemingly exclusive "commitment" of the parents at Elkhorn...Please tell me you didn't say that!! That comment gives verbal ammunition to a lot of people. I hope you are sitting down when you read the responses to your very narrow-minded comment. "

nocoen wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:43 PM:

" I am an Elkhorn GATE parent and am sick and tired of the meme about "priveledge" status of Elkhorn. It ain't true. Every parent that I have met with kids @ Elkhorn is hard working ... the only difference btw Elkhorn and the other district schools is the parents committment to their kids education. If that makes us elite, so be it. If your kid rides a LUSD bus, I am paying for it. Why can't my kid ride a bus home? No one can answer that one... "

Bob Hussein Loblaw wrote on Aug 19, 2008 6:25 PM:

" Zinfandel -- Easy tiger. I'm with you. Maybe you skipped my comment earlier in the discussion. "

Zinfandel wrote on Aug 19, 2008 4:13 PM:

" GATEmom . . .the only children who have "exclusive schools in LUSD" are GATE children". I am sure that if parents of "special needs children" or as you addressed them as "disabled students" where given an "exclusive school" they would be more than happy to drive their children!!!

How about disabled students? I would assume by the comments here that they should be forced to pay too as their parents must choose to send them to exclusive schools just for children with special needs. "


Report Abuse "

Zinfandel wrote on Aug 19, 2008 4:07 PM:

" GATEmom wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:41 AM:

" There are no GATE programs at the middle school level. I also seem to recall at the beginning of this year that LUSD transportation had a school bus parked in front of In and Out Burger with a large sign that they were hiring full and part-time drivers. Hmm..
Yes, GATE is exclusive, you have to qualify based on test scores, recommendations, and passing an assessment test. My child qualified based on his academic merit and talent. Do charter schools have their bussing as pay-as-you go? How about disabled students? I would assume by the comments here that they should be forced to pay too as their parents must choose to send them to exclusive schools just for children with special needs. "
GATEmom, Your child attends Elkhorn by choice. . .special ed children do not attend the schools they are assigned by choice. . .not all school have special ed classes. That is why they are provided transportation. GATE children attend Elkhorn by choice. It really is very simple to understand. "

Observer wrote on Aug 19, 2008 3:32 PM:

" Ok, I think that's a reasonable compromise asking parents to find transportation for their children. As a former GATE parent I can assure you that there are many children from families that cannot afford the costs. However, they will make it happen. "

SportsGuru wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:56 PM:

" To GATEmom:

There is no need for GATE at the middle school level because placement varies by each student's academic acumen.

The only reason parents need to even consider middle school GATE would be for bragging rights.

I have two kids that went through the GATE program at Vinewood and the oldest is now at a University. She didn't need the exclusivity of Elkhorn to get herself there. She just needed to dedicate herself to her studies. "

SportsGuru wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:50 PM:

" .... (continued) besides ... Lodi Unified needs the money to buy more Binders at Lodi High .... ;) "

SportsGuru wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:49 PM:

" It is REALLY hard to feel bad about the priviledged GATE kids who get to have their cake (going to Elkhorn) and eat it to (free transportation).

But as many pointed out here, if you want the priviledge of going to Elkhorn be willing to pay the cost of the "extras" that come along with NOT going to school at the schoolhouse assigned to your child based on where you live.

If you want an education that is "better" than your normal school (which your child could probably walk to), then don't expect us tax payers to cover transport costs to_get_them_there! "

Bob Loblaw wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:06 PM:

" GATEmom -- I can see your point with charter school kids, but not special ed kids. Not all schools have a Special Day Class and many times the SDC their child qualifies for is across town. "

Rhodie wrote on Aug 19, 2008 2:02 PM:

" "As far as the free lunches that program sucks and is abused another waste of money whos ever it is."

Alright parents, do any of you have problems with charges showing up on your kids accounts when they haven't have a school lunch? Last year one of my kids was always getting 10 and 5 cent charges on the meal card when I sent him in with a dollar and two quarters. How do they charge ten cents when two quarters are given?

I called to ask if I put a bulk sum on thier account how would I know if it all would go to them and not these ficticous charges and the response was call in everyday you find the wrong charges and they'd fix it. Why don't they just use a system which doesn't have erronious charges on it? I know all that extra lunch money isn't going to bussing, I wonder where it is going. "

Rhodie wrote on Aug 19, 2008 1:57 PM:

" " To all who posted below. WELL SAID ! If its your choice to attend ELK HORN then figure out a way to get your kids to school. You'd have to take them if they attended a private school."

I don't have a problem driving my kids to Elkhorn, I prefer that than the alternative. My gripe is that they waited until a week before school started to tell us we'd have to bus them after telling us during the spring ans summer that there would be bussing.

I really wish they had planned Elkhorn better and had it in the middle of the LUSD. Tucked off to the very south when it draws kids in from all over the district is just poor planning. Which seems rampant in the School District. "

flowerchild wrote on Aug 19, 2008 1:33 PM:

" I'm surprised that the parents of these 'gifted' children would even want them on a bus. The fumes alone burn brain cells. I qualified for GATE programs in school, but my dad didn't want me in special ed. "

GATEmom wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:41 AM:

" There are no GATE programs at the middle school level. I also seem to recall at the beginning of this year that LUSD transportation had a school bus parked in front of In and Out Burger with a large sign that they were hiring full and part-time drivers. Hmm..
Yes, GATE is exclusive, you have to qualify based on test scores, recommendations, and passing an assessment test. My child qualified based on his academic merit and talent. Do charter schools have their bussing as pay-as-you go? How about disabled students? I would assume by the comments here that they should be forced to pay too as their parents must choose to send them to exclusive schools just for children with special needs. "

Oh Bull wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:20 AM:

" To all who posted below. WELL SAID ! If its your choice to attend ELK HORN then figure out a way to get your kids to school. You'd have to take them if they attended a private school.
As far as the free lunches that program sucks and is abused another waste of money whos ever it is. "

Vickster wrote on Aug 19, 2008 11:10 AM:

" Lodian...
You are right on the money...No pun intended. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:29 AM:

" It's like being on an intra-district transfer. If you choose to go to Elkhorn instead of your own school (in your boundary) you are responsible for your child's transportation. All intra-district transfer students are responsible for their own transportation. "

Lodian wrote on Aug 19, 2008 9:26 AM:

" Observer wrote on Aug 19, 2008 7:43 AM:

" Why would you just cut bus service to Elkhorn. Why wouldn't you do it for all schools? "

Observer: They see attending Elkhorn as a choice. "

Vickster wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:28 AM:

" Elkhorn is a school of choice, not a local neighborhood school. There are GATE programs at local schools, but families chose to go to the exlusive school. And I believe the Free Lunch Program is a Program from the State and not paid with District funds. "

Jeff wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:27 AM:

" Isn't Elkhorn a school of choice? Isn't a choice to have your child go there? If this is true, then parents can choose to drive them, or choose to pay for bussing, or choose to keep them at their local school. There are, I believe, no students that are mandated to attend Elkhorn, therefore there is no mandated bussing. Pay as you go. "

wtf wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:18 AM:

" This is BS. When I was a kid, schools were within WALKING distance. When my kids went to school, the government, in their illustrious wisdom came up with **forced busing** and now they want the parents to pay for it?

Why don't they go back to local schools where the kids can walk to school. All of my schools were within walking distance when I grew up. The elementary school was the closest, middle school a little further away and the high school was the farthest.

It would save $$$$, save the environment and give the kids some much needed exercise. "

Oh Bull wrote on Aug 19, 2008 8:10 AM:

" Cut the free lunch program from all the schools and then spend the money on transportation to and from all schools. After all I would rather make sure my child has a ride to school. Do the math lunches $1.50/$2.50.(pack a lunch kids will eat) Gas $4.00 gallon which goes about say 10 miles per gallon and bus picks up 4 kids withnin the 10 miles. "

Observer wrote on Aug 19, 2008 7:43 AM:

" Why would you just cut bus service to Elkhorn. Why wouldn't you do it for all schools? "

Comments on this story are now closed.