Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Indexes

November 2nd, 2009
November 7th, 2009
November 6th, 2009
November 5th, 2009
November 4th, 2009
November 3rd, 2009
November 2nd, 2009
ADVERTISEMENT
Galt City Councilwoman Barbara Payne sprays water on her yard Monday afternoon on Silver Spruce Court. Payne was fined $100 last week for watering the lawn of an abandoned home next door. Also pictured are Payne's neighbors, Jack Hornor, left, and Gary Masuda, who also helped to take care of the home that is located in the background.(Brian Feulner/News-Sentinel)

Galt councilwoman fined

Barbara Payne cited for watering lawn of abandoned home; city says water connection could have led to 'cross contamination'

By Chris Nichols
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Wednesday, June 4, 2008 2:53 PM PDT

Two weeks after Galt City Council members urged the public to help keep up abandoned homes, one of them has been fined $100 for doing just that.

Barbara Payne received a citation from the city's Public Works department last week for watering the lawn of an abandoned home next door — a violation of the city's code.

Memo from Galt Public Works Director Gregg Halladay.

Payne said she and a group of about five neighbors had been watering and cutting the lawn at 121 Silver Spruce Court for the past month to prevent the foreclosed home from becoming a neighborhood eyesore.

"I have to say it wasn't a good feeling," the councilwoman said of finding the citation stuck under her doormat last week. "If you're trying to do something good, why should you be fined for it?"

Galt Public Works Director Gregg Halladay said Payne's case wasn't just a matter of sprinkling a bit of water next door — which is "technically" a violation in itself, he noted.

A hose had been hooked up from the outside faucet of the Payne household to the outside faucet of the abandoned home, allowing neighbors to manually turn on an existing sprinkler system at the abandoned home.

The connection, however, created the potential for "cross contamination of the water system," the director said.

Should a drop in water pressure have occurred — say, from a fire hydrant being used — mud, insects or stagnant pool water could have been sucked up from the abandoned property and funneled into the Payne's home or into the water system itself, Halladay said.

A regular check of the water system found no such contamination, he noted.

Halladay said a public works staff member noticed the connection during a "vacancy check," made to ensure the abandoned home's water was shut off.

Council members at their May 20 meeting, including Mayor Andrew Meredith, told residents to take matters into their own hands to fight foreclosure-related blight, following public comments about abandoned properties popping up in Galt.

Meredith said Monday he stands by those words of encouragement. He just doesn't want to see residents do what Payne did.

"She made an illegal connection — she trespassed onto her neighbor's property," said Meredith, who has clashed with Payne on numerous occasions over city policy.

He noted the connection could have provided water pressure throughout the abandoned home, and potentially flooded the home.

City Manager Ted Anderson at the May 20 meeting had suggested residents contact Galt's code enforcement officers regarding blight.



The watering of an abandoned home on Silver Spruce Court in Galt led to a $100 fine for Barbara Payne, who tried using her own water to maintain the home's lawn. (Brian Feulner/News-Sentinel)




The Galt Municipal Code, Section 13.08.180, states "No person shall supply water from his own service to any other premise unless written authorization from the Director is obtained. The Director shall authorize such connection on a temporary basis only to facilitate repairs on the water system or for health and safety."

"We considered this health and safety," noted Georgeann Hornor, who along with her husband, Jack, helped keep up the abandoned home. "We didn't want people moving in there. Obviously, it's an abandoned house."

Payne said the matter is not on tonight's council agenda, but might be brought up.

The lawn at 121 Silver Spruce Court is now starting to dry out. Neighbors had hoped they could keep it from turning into a dead brown mass, full of thick weeds like other abandoned properties in the neighborhood.

"There were a lot of us trying to keep the place up," said Jack Hornor. "We're not now."

Contact reporter Chris Nichols at chrisn@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

Robb wrote on Jun 7, 2008 5:53 PM:

" Bla Bla Bla, pay the fine... "

Cogito wrote on Jun 7, 2008 9:32 AM:

" YEAH! What papercut said, DITTO! "

papercut wrote on Jun 6, 2008 10:20 PM:

" The only way you could have operated that sprinkler system was to make a connection to one of the lawn sprinklers themselves in front of the anti-syphon valves, not at the hose-bibb behind the anti-syphon and on the house supply side of the water system. Pay your fine, shut your mouth and accept the consequences for your utter stupidity. "

papercut wrote on Jun 6, 2008 10:13 PM:

" neighbor, if this sprinkler system supposedly had anti-syphon valves like you say it did, then why would a plumber be so stupid as to bleed the sprinkler system? Why did it take you finally 3 days to make up yet a different excuse and why did they get the ticket and not offer the same explanation as you if he's the so-called PLUMMER? The sprinkler system operates from the same water supply as the hose bibb it was connected to, which also supplies the house water. You're story doesn't even hold water. "

neighbor wrote on Jun 6, 2008 4:07 PM:

" I was directly involved in this issue, so please let me explain how it all went down. My husband, Jack, and Barbaras husband were standing outside his garage discussing the fact that the lawn on the foreclosed home was starting to turn brown. Jack is retired, so he volunteered to water the lawn enough to keep it from dying if he could use the hose from the Paynes home. The hose wouldnt reach every place, so Barbaras husband, who is a plumber, said he would hook the hose to the other homes sprinkler system at their outdoor faucet. The water to the home had been cut off at the curb, so while a realtor was with him, he pressurized the system and went into the house to verify there were no leaks and no open faucets. The system was pressurized ONLY for the few minutes when he was watering. The sprinklers for that house all have anti-syphon valves, so no contaminated water could go into the Paynes home. After Jack was through watering, he turned off the water and bled the sprinkler system. The amount of water used was minimal. "

dw wrote on Jun 6, 2008 11:13 AM:

" With Arnold declaring a drought in the State of CA, I don't think anyone should be watering vacant lots. Let the lawns turn brown. Talk about wasting precious water! Get over the aesthetics--look at the big picture, people! "

Cogito wrote on Jun 5, 2008 10:07 PM:

" Good point Swoozie, I got a ticket for speeding a while back because I wasn't paying attention to what I was doing. It cost me about 300 dollars, and a day in traffic school (which is 8 hours of your life you can't get back). This story has taught me a lot about Ms. Payne. What a publicity wh.........hound. She lost any chance of me voting for her come reelection time. Pay your fine and SHUT UP!................PUHLEEZE! "

swoozie08 wrote on Jun 4, 2008 8:37 PM:

" I am really concerned about this as a Galt voter. As a city council person, she of all people should be a model citizen. Take the fine without complaint, quit blaming others and pay the violation. You broke the law. By Barbara Payne whining about the fine, she is not showing the citizens of Galt (who voted for her) how to abide by the rules. I heard her on KFBK this afternoon (06/04) and she once again claimed that hooked up the hose to the vacant lot's sprinklers. It was in the spirit of neighborly conduct but she made a mistake. Okay - so it may have been an innocent mistake. Take the fine, learn from your mistake, learn your city ordinances, especially, if you are a member of the Galt City Council. This is one voter who will support another candidate in the future - given that he or she is not whining about a mistake of their own doing. "

Lapdog wrote on Jun 4, 2008 8:02 PM:

" SHE LIED TO THE PRESS AND TO HER CONSTITUENTS!! Barbara was not innocently "watering" the lawn. She connected a hose from her house to the main water line on the neighbor's house. She did not include a backflow preventer. This creates a health risk. Providing water to the abandoned house INCREASES the risk of vagrancy. What the City Council encouraged was to take a sprinkler at the end of a hose connected to one's house and water the neighbor's yard, moving the hose and sprinkler around the yard. Finally, Public Works tried to give the citation to her but she was not home. They then left it at her door. This was not evasive maneuver as Barabara has the gall to claim. Sure, help keep your neighborhood looking good, but do it in a responsible manner. Oh, and if one gets caught doing something stupid, don't go to the press with misrepresented facts! "

TJP wrote on Jun 4, 2008 6:14 PM:

" Neighbor: your comment of June 3 can be found under popular stories read, Councilwoman fined for fighting blight. "

neighbor wrote on Jun 4, 2008 2:09 PM:

" I posted a comment yesterday explaining why there was no chance for cross contamination no water running in the house. It appeared before I logged off, but then it must have been pulled. I would like to know why, because it was not controversial at all. "

Cogito wrote on Jun 4, 2008 8:31 AM:

" Cdawg, what makes Galt a great place to live are the people who live here. All cities get people elected to office who make dumb ordinances. I mean, hasn't Lodi had their water police out patrolling your neighborhoods for years? I can see the point during drought years, but they were put in place and kept there. Us Galtonians like each other, look out for each other, and try to ignore most of the shenanigans that happen at city hall. But this bunch we have now, may be the worst ever. That's why I find enjoyment out of one of them getting fined by an ordinance that may have been not all that well thought out. "

cdawg wrote on Jun 4, 2008 8:15 AM:

" I guess I do not have to point out how hypocritical this sounds

Help the neighborhood; mow the lawn and pull the weeds.

Water the lawn and you are trespassing..

Way to run out your citizens... "

cdawg wrote on Jun 4, 2008 8:00 AM:

" Keep it up council and Mayor and you will run out every good citizen in your city. Then you can have your blight and your gang bangers.. I hate Galt.. "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2008 9:26 PM:

" The picture kind of has that "American Gothic" vibe. "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2008 9:22 PM:

" Midtowner, "jokes on us"? So you think this is funny? Cause I think it's HILARIOUS! Goofy picture on the front page and all. I may frame this issue! "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2008 9:17 PM:

" Papercut, common criminal on our council? Hey, things are looking up! Maybe I should run. I've never been arrested, but I do ride my bicycle without a helmet. I'm only a head injury away from being qualified. "

midtowner wrote on Jun 3, 2008 8:31 PM:

" Way to go COG! This is a prime example of hypocricy. Joke's on you Galt citizens. "

HappyDays94 wrote on Jun 3, 2008 4:32 PM:

" Good, I'm glad that she got fined. You cannot be a hyprocrate and expect never to get caught doing wrong. Payne likes to stir the pot if you know what I mean, now it's her turn in the lime light. : ) "

wtf wrote on Jun 3, 2008 1:05 PM:

" Saw Barbara's letter to the editor in the LNS yesterday and again, I'll say the banks who foreclosed on the properties should be held accountable for their upkeep once the homes are empty.

Something else to think about: We had minimal rain fall this past winter and more than likely, water rationing will be coming up this summer. Why waste the minimal amount of water you're allowed on an empty house? Make the banks accountable and fine them if necessary. "

boonablis wrote on Jun 3, 2008 11:23 AM:

" A fine??? She should have got a medal-
I mean the place is a dump. Kudos to that chick "

papercut wrote on Jun 3, 2008 10:49 AM:

" Couldn't some of those redevelopment funds be used to buy new sod for that home? How about holding the realtor, builder and developer accountable for selling that $175,000 home for $400,00 that's now worth $150,000? Mr. Raboy should have some answers for you. He sold Galt to the highest bidder for many years and now your next two generatioons will be in extreme debt. "

papercut wrote on Jun 3, 2008 10:44 AM:

" Cogito, that's funny. You now have a common criminal amongst your council. Mr. Meredith, don't let up and it's time all these old croakers in both Lodi and Galt were sent packing with all of their old, lame and same old attitudes. None of them can function without a con artist, scam man, called a city manager. "

papercut wrote on Jun 3, 2008 10:36 AM:

" Looks like that little parking strip in that picture has dead grass at the end where a vehicle has apparently been parked and leaking automotive contaminants into the ground there. I'd be a little more worried about the cockroaches breeding in that vacant house than anything else. You may have even flooded the interior if someone came in and stole any appliance or fixture that was attached to the water supply or left a water tap on. You need to have the owner check to see if that indeed happen. If you flooded that interior there's going to be some pretty strong mold and mildew growth in there that you will be entirely responsible for. "

newsuscrib wrote on Jun 3, 2008 10:33 AM:

" The nerve!! I watch the City Council meetings, it was a suggestion by Tim Raboy to go over and take care of your neigbhors yard, quickly backed by Mayor Meredith (as always!) that sent good neighbor Barbara Payne and her neighbors over to take care of the abandoned yard. Now the Mayor is on his high horse chastising Payne about tresspassing and cross contamination. Give me a break!! Refund the $100 fine. In the future, Councilmen,use more care in your suggestions. "

LodiJoe wrote on Jun 3, 2008 10:20 AM:

" I am thinking the City of Galt should have paid Barbara Payne $100 for trying to improve the abandoned property. I once witnessed City employees being taken to lunch in a banquet room, complete with singing entertainer. They need the money, singers are expensive. "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2008 8:14 AM:

" T&C, "innovative"? Galt? I've lived here most of my life, and if our council lacks the ability to do anything, it's to have a good idea. "

T & C wrote on Jun 3, 2008 7:57 AM:

" I Love It! The City asks everyone to pitch in and help keep foreclosed properties look nice; "You know, have pride in your neighborhood"! Then when you do something because "You Care"...They fine you! Sounds like a money making inovative idea by The City Of Galt! "

fred117 wrote on Jun 3, 2008 7:55 AM:

" Ok, Let's see. The Public Works Director was at the meeting when the board approved the fact that neighbors should help keep up adjoining properties. Why didn't someone (The Director) take the initiative to let the public know that there are certain things that do violate this approval. I will be honest I have been watering and mowing a lawn by hand on a local house that is empty in Galt. That has stopped effective today!!! To hek with the City. I request the Fire Department post all houses that are abandoned and the dead grass is over grown as a fire hazard. I will be sending a letter to the Fire Chief about this problem immediately. I do not agree with the way that Barbara and her neighbors did it but there intentions were good. Does it really surprise anyone that Andrew Meredith would bad mouth Barbara instead of standing up for his(and the Councils) decision. I think the Council should let all Galt residents know what they can and can't do because Meredith is already accusing Barbara of trespassing which they(the council) approved. How can you water and take care of a property without trespassing. Just thinking out loud!! Have a Great Day to All!! "

Cogito wrote on Jun 3, 2008 7:41 AM:

" This story received two days coverage? A $100 fine? You get a bigger fine for going 10 MPH over the speed limit. Is it me, or is this the goofiest looking picture you've ever seen in the paper? Ms. Paynes grass doesn't look too good either. If you want the house next door to be sold Ms. Payne, you need to move that eyesore of a behemoth motor home to a proper storage facility. Only in Galt indeed. "

GetUrHeadOut wrote on Jun 3, 2008 7:23 AM:

" You have got to be kidding me!!! Only in Galt!!! "

CLH wrote on Jun 3, 2008 7:15 AM:

" Why don`t the people help each other. I get sick and tired of ugly yards. "

galt citizen wrote on Jun 3, 2008 6:59 AM:

" I guess the public works director forgot that Barbara voted for a huge increase in salary for him and he got a secret bonus! I bet she won't be voting for that again when his review comes due. Hey Barbara, why don't you work on getting this city ordinance changed at your next city council meeting. I do agree however that she did violate the law and she did deserve a fine, as we all would expect if we did the same. "

veritas wrote on Jun 3, 2008 6:54 AM:

" Sounds like Gregg's underwear is pulled up way too tight and wound up even tighter. I can think of a lot better solutions than sneaking a $ 100 fine under someone's dormat. What a loser. "

gottago wrote on Jun 3, 2008 6:51 AM:

" The best thing that Galt should have done was give a warning and and suggest how Galt can make the city look better with neighbors helping each other.I will do my best to do the right thing.The question is "will you?"
Al Baldwin, Galt "

john95632 wrote on Jun 3, 2008 6:18 AM:

" Fined for watering the grass. Hey Code Enforcement officers of Galt, How about do something about all these garage sale sign being posted around Galt. Are you going to fine me for taking them down? Do something now, they are breaking the law. BTW you can find them on the signs they post. $100 for watering the grass!! Get a life. "

Comments on this story are now closed.