Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Indexes

November 20th, 2009
November 19th, 2009
November 18th, 2009
November 17th, 2009
November 16th, 2009
November 14th, 2009
November 13th, 2009
ADVERTISEMENT

Lodi's St. John's future up in air

San Joaquin Diocese to decide on whether to stay with Episcopal Church

By Ross Farrow
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Saturday, December 1, 2007 7:07 AM PST

The future of the Episcopal Church in the Central Valley is clearly up in the air as the San Joaquin Diocese votes next week on whether to remain in the Episcopal Church USA, a division of the English-based Anglican Church, or seek a more socially conservative organization within the Anglican Church.

The issue pits conservative and liberal factions on issues like homosexuality and woman priests. The San Joaquin Diocese is among four dioceses considering leaving Episcopal Church USA over social issues.

And Lodi's St. John's Episcopal Church is right in the middle of the crossfire. While the congregation is divided over homosexuality, it is united in its desire for the San Joaquin Diocese to remain intact and not leave the American Episcopal Church, according to Andee Zetterbaum, one of four voting delegates representing St. John's at next week's convention.

The 77-million-member Anglican Communion is a fellowship of churches that trace their roots to the Church of England. It is the third-largest Christian body in the world, behind the Roman Catholic and Orthodox churches, and is represented in the U.S. by the Episcopal Church.

After four years of emergency summits and failed talks over the consecration of the openly gay bishop V. Eugene Robinson of New Hampshire, Episcopal bishops have been pressured by conservative Anglican leaders worldwide to roll back their support for gays.

In the United States, about 65 of the more than 7,000 parishes are either breaking with the national church or have lost most of their clergy in similar disputes.

San Joaquin is one of four dioceses considering an invitation to align with an Anglican group outside the United States. The others are in Fort Worth, Texas, Pittsburgh, Pa, and Quincy, Ill. The leadership of all four dioceses share conservative values.

Galt is not in the San Joaquin Diocese. It is in the neighboring Northern California Diocese, which doesn't consider Robinson's ordination a controversial issue.

The issues to be raised at next week's convention raises more questions than it answers. There is substantial disagreement locally and nationally on what authority Schofield and the San Joaquin Diocese convention delegates have. There is also debate about how much authority Katharine Jefferts Schori, the presiding bishop of the national organization, has. Jefferts Schori is at odds theologically with Schofield.

"It's going to be messy," Zetterbaum said.

The San Joaquin Diocese convention will be held for a half-day beginning at 11 a.m. on Friday and all day on Dec. 8 beginning at 9 a.m. It will be held in the community building at St. James Cathedral, 4147 E. Dakota Ave., Fresno.

Diocese officials might provide live streaming capability for the public to view the convention on their computer, said diocese spokesman Van McCalister.

Here are some of the key players in the San Joaquin Diocese's future:

Bishop John-David Schofield

Schofield was consecrated on Oct. 9, 1988, and assumed his duties on Dec. 15 of the same year. He oversees the San Joaquin Diocese, which consists of 48 Episcopal parishes from Lodi to Bakersfield, and east to Mammoth Lakes and Ridgecrest.


John-David Schofield

Schofield has his devout friends and enemies. He strongly believes that the Episcopal Church USA violated biblical principles by consecrating the openly gay Bishop, V. Eugene Robinson of New Hampshire. He also opposes such issues as abortion and woman priests.

Schofield maintains that he has no unilateral authority to take his diocese out of the American church. That lies with the delegates at next week's convention.

He also invites St. John's or any other church that disagrees with the convention's vote regarding the diocese's future to leave the diocese.

"If they are free of debt, they can take away their buildings, their priests, the works, and they can go with my blessings," Schofield told the News-Sentinel during a visit to Lodi in February.

In a written statement on Nov. 16, Schofield announced that the Anglican Church of the Southern Cone of South America, meeting in Chile in November, invited the San Joaquin Diocese and any conservative dioceses to leave the American Episcopal Church and join the its group. The Southern Cone also invited conservative Canadian Anglicans to join.

The Episcopal Church USA is part of the British-based Anglican Communion, formerly the Church of England. Canada, which has a different organization called the Anglican Church of Canada, is also divided among liberal and conservative groups.

"We welcome the invitation extended by the Anglican Church of the southern Cone," Schofield said. "The invitation assures the diocese's place in the Anglican Communion and full communion with the See of Canterbury."

Schofield added that the diocese will be free to join the South American Anglican group provided that San Joaquin convention delegates approve a series of amendments to the diocese constitution next week. A two-thirds majority is required.

The amendments include language that lists the diocese as a member of the Anglican Communion rather than Episcopal Church USA and that the diocese bishop has ecclesiastical authority rather than the nationwide presiding bishop.

Katharine Jefferts Schori


Katharine Jefferts Schori

Jefferts Schori is presiding bishop of the Episcopal Church USA. She has sent letters stating that if convention delegates at San Joaquin and other conservative dioceses adopt amendments to their constitution opposing the national Episcopal church, she will ask a special review committee to determine whether Schofield and the San Joaquin delegates have "abandoned" the communion of the Episcopal Church.

Jefferts Schori, 53, was bishop of the Nevada Diocese before being named presiding bishop nationally in November 2006.

A ruling favorable to Jefferts Schori could result in her removing Schofield as bishop of the San Joaquin Diocese and the convention delegates. An "assisting bishop" would fill in on a temporary basis until a new bishop is selected.

Andee Zetterbaum

A Stockton resident, Zetterbaum is a lay Eucharist minister at St. John's and one of four voting convention delegates representing St. John's. The three other voting delegates are Ejae Brown, Richard Cress and Jim "Corky" Kuykendall.

Parish priests are also allowed to vote, but St. John's doesn't have a permanent priest. Interim Priest Basil Parker-Matthews doesn't have a vote, Zetterbaum said.


Andee Zetterbaum

Zetterbaum strongly opposes any movement by the San Joaquin Diocese to leave Episcopal Church USA. She says that Schofield signed a contract with the national church that she considers to be equivalent to a prenuptial agreement saying the bishop will be "loyal to the denomination."

Despite her protests, Zetterbaum expects convention delegates to pass constitutional amendments that could lead to the diocese's departure from the American church.

Schofield has widespread support among delegates, she said, because priests and parishioners who disagree with him theologically have left their congregation for other churches.

Schofield's desire for the San Joaquin Diocese to consider another affiliation has made it difficult for St. John's to get select a new priest to replace Father Rick matters, who left in May for a church in Carmel — and a new diocese.

"We have had priests who have said, 'I love the Central Valley, but as long as Schofield is bishop, I won't apply, ' " Zetterbaum said.

Zetterbaum said it isn't clear whether Schofield or convention delegates have the authority to join the Southern Cone of South America. It's an issue that could very well be decided in court, she said.

"St. John's has made it clear it will remain in the (American) Episcopal Church." Zetterbaum said.

Van McCalister

McCalister wears several hats with the San Joaquin Diocese. He is a priest at a small Episcopal church in Corcoran, south of Fresno and is the diocese's vocations officer, dean of the Schools for Ministry and public relations officer. He also conducts training to prevent sexual misconduct within the diocese.


Van McCalister

McCalister says that someday, the Central Valley could have separate Episcopal and Anglican dioceses.

Church officials disagree on what authority dioceses and the national church have, McCalister said, because they're venturing into uncharted territory.

"The framers of the Constitution and Canons of the Episcopal Church never envisioned this kind of scenario," he said. "There is nothing stating how to get out of the Episcopal Church."

There's more confusion because Presiding Bishop Katharine Jefferts Schori is "trying to introduce a hierarchical model into the church as if we're Catholic or Orthodox," McCalister said.

The Episcopal and Anglican churches don't have a pope like the Roman Catholic Church does. No one in the Episcopal Church or Anglican Communion as the same authority that a pope has, McCalister said.

"The Episcopal Church was put together by pretty much the same people who put together the U.S. government in the 18th century," he said. "We have college of bishops. (Jefferts Schori) is trying to frame herself as an archbishop or primate. There's no such thing. She can't remove a bishop unless the post has been abandoned."




The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Contact Religion Editor Ross Farrow at rossf@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

What Church? wrote on Dec 4, 2007 8:01 PM:

" The Episcopal Church has lost all credibility. But then a church formed because Henry VIII wanted to get his grove on has always been suspect. Why would Robinson want to rip the church apart? Personal ambition? Shame... "

James Carrington wrote on Dec 4, 2007 9:05 AM:

" "...consecration of the openly gay bishop V. Eugene Robinson of New Hampshire..." This was the watershed moment in the devolvement of the Episcopal Church USA. What were they thinking? Out of the dozens maybe hundreds of qualified Bishops this was the best they could do ? It was a stick in the eye to all congregations and they are now paying the price. "

12x wrote on Dec 4, 2007 8:50 AM:

" To Van McCalister: Here's how you get out of the Episcopal church; walk out the door! If we don't seek to know the truth of God's Word, we are susceptible to apostasy. As Christians we must guard against any false teachings that would distract us from the truth preached by the apostles and written in God's Word. There are many Bible preaching/teaching churches up and down the valley that rightfully divide the word of truth. "

12x wrote on Dec 4, 2007 8:40 AM:

" To Andee Zetterbaum: You appear to be choosing loyalty to "the denomination" as a priority to your loyalty to God. Your words clearly demonstrate who is the god of your life. The denomination's culture-influenced platform is a apostasy to the clear and knowable truth of God's word. "

12x wrote on Dec 4, 2007 8:29 AM:

" To Katharine Jefferts Schori: It is the Episcopal Church USA who has abandoned it's congregation by abandoning the clear teaching of the Bible, which transcends time and culture. "

Episcolute wrote on Dec 3, 2007 10:57 AM:

" This article is fairly written and received opinions from all the parties; that is great! However, the banner in the LNS from last Saturday was a bit much. The future of Lodi's St. John's IS NOT up in the air! The church WILL continue as a loving, viable congregation, standing in the Episcopal AND Anglican tradition, worshipping God within our tradition and reaching out to ALL people. "

Comments on this story are now closed.



Leaf Pickup