Camanche Reservoir flooded tiny village

Elaine MacDonnell walked through the ruins of the town where she was born and raised.

The year was 1988, and a severe drought dropped the water in Camanche Reservoir to its lowest level since it was filled in 1963. The town of Camanche, which had been inundated by the reservoir, had emerged.

MacDonnell, 82, recalled strolling past the crumbling foundation of her home.

"I found toys in the mud that my children played with," she said. "It was like walking into the past."

MacDonnell remembers Camanche before the man-made flood that destroyed her home and displaced the residents of the historic mining community.

The town was a fun place to grow up, she said. There was lots of nature to explore, hills and trees to climb, and there was always a party to go to.

MacDonnell was born and raised in Camanche, a small town on the banks of the Mokelumne River.

"It was a very nice little town," she said. "We had big barbecues and dances in the dance hall. There was always something going on. We used to spend our days floating on the river."

MacDonnell was 37 when she was forced to leave the town along with the other 50 to 100 residents. In 1962, East Bay Municipal Utility District condemned more than 7,000 acres of land to make way for the flood control Camanche Reservoir.

An old EBMUD newspaper ad from the time says, "We hope you remember the people of Camanche and their sacrifice for your future."

MacDonnell recalls her sacrifice.

Her late husband, James, who worked in the Pacific Clay sand mine before it was shuttered, packed up the homestead in the family's 1932 Ford truck and they moved to Ione. Some landowners fought EBMUD, but in the end most of the residents went quietly, according to Sal Manna, a west Calaveras County historian.

Manna has a collection of old newspaper articles documenting the fate of Camanche. The town's original name, Limerick, was changed to Camanche in 1849. Many of the settlers came from Camanche, Iowa.

Drowned towns of California

More than 30 towns across the state were inundated by water to make way for reservoirs. Most of the towns had long been abandoned before they were flooded. Here are some of the most notable inhabited towns that were inundated:

• In 1957, the Solano County town of Monticello was evacuated to make way for Lake Berryessa. The town had a population of 250. Life Magazine chronicled the citizens of Monticello as they moved their belongings out of town.

• The town of Kernville once sat along the banks of the Kern River. When the river was dammed to form Lake Isabella in 1953, the entire Kern County town was moved to higher ground. Now the historic gold mining town has a population of about 2,000 and is a thriving tourist spot.

• At one time the Lake County town of Gravelly Valley had a hotel, general merchandise store, a sawmill, a post office and a school. In 1921, the Scott Dam was built. The post office was moved a mile, all of the buildings were torn down and the graves in the cemetery were moved to make way for Lake Pillsbury.

• The town of Kennett was a copper mining hub from the turn of the 20th century until 1925. It once boasted a population of 10,000 people. Declining copper prices after World War I hit the town hard. It was abandoned in 1944 when the Shasta Dam was built, and it now sits under 400 feet of Lake Shasta water.

— News-Sentinel staff

Manna said the town boomed during the Gold Rush and its population topped out at 1,500.

The settlers were a diverse group, Manna said, coming from Ireland, Italy, China, France and Mexico.

"It was a wild and woolly place," Manna said. "There were a lot of knife fights, a lot of bars."

By the 1960s, the town's population had dipped to less than 100. Residents were given a year to leave their homes before the structures were torn down and the site was flooded. Even the graves were dug up and the coffins moved to other cemeteries in the area.

"There were some amazing stories, but because the town was inundated, their history kind of got lost," Manna said. "Camanche was a dramatic wiping away of history."

MacDonnell recalls the day she had to leave her home, which took her husband seven years to build out of pumice bricks.

"It was a very sad time to see all the destruction," she said. "We had no say. We just had to be out of there. We hated to leave with all the work my husband put into it."

Monte MacDonnell, one of five kids Elaine and James MacDonnell raised in Camanche, was 12 when he had to leave. He watched the one-room school house, where his siblings, his parents and his grandparents went to school, crumble under an EBMUD bulldozer.

"My dad made sure we were the last ones to leave town," he said. "We were devastated."

Today, the foundations of the buildings and a faint outline of the streets are all that's left of the town that sits at the bottom of Camanche Reservoir near the south shore marina.

In dry years, you can see the ruins of the town through the murky water.

Reader Feedback

Pam Asher wrote on Jul 23, 2007 10:36 AM:

" I guess my question would be were any of these families compensated when forced to leave? Does any one know? "

Report Abuse

Brian wrote on Jul 21, 2007 10:17 PM:

" I have a special insert from the News Sentinel of pictures of Commanche before it was flooded by the new dam. This was in the early sixties. I wonder if anyone else saved this? "

Report Abuse

fil wrote on Jul 17, 2007 7:44 PM:

" I go boating every chance i ge to take my family. We do have a good time. I do have alot of respect for the lake.Knowing there was a sacrifice for me to be there. In one sense, it was a terrible way to get rid of the town, But , just respect the terain just like the owners of the property did. Really sorry for what happened. "

Report Abuse

Cheryl Bolles wrote on Jul 16, 2007 4:13 PM:

" July 16, 2007, I live at North Shore Lake Camanche and EBMUD is trying to repeat history. They have proposed a change in their watershed management which would elimate the Mobile Home Parks here at the lake and displace almost 200 families. There is a public meetin July 26, 2007 at La Contenta Golf Course, at 7pm for public comments to allow us some imput. Your story was great. "

Report Abuse

Hanford Reader wrote on Jul 16, 2007 12:48 PM:

" Great Story! I only wish we could see the pictures the family took back in 1988 during the drought. Maybe a follow up story someday soon? "

Report Abuse

Jaci Hugo (MacDonnell) wrote on Jul 15, 2007 12:54 PM:

" Elaine MacDonnell is my Grandmother and Monte MacDonnell is my Dad. I remember driving through the old town of Camanche during the drought with my dad. I was amazed to see that the old bridge was still there, my dad has a picture of he and I on the bridge. It was amazing to see the toys that my family dug up in the old sand box (which was still there). I am glad that Lodi News has taken the time to remember our family's history. Thank you. "

Report Abuse

E. wrote on Jul 14, 2007 8:49 PM:

" Nice article. When I was a kid, I remember getting the creeps swimming in that lake knowing there was a submerged town underneath, but it provided the basis for some good ghost stories. "

Report Abuse

savannah mccarthy wrote on Jul 14, 2007 6:46 PM:

" Hi, Elaine Macdonnell is my great grandmother. I was shocked to see this artical because i didnt really think that anyone cared about that old town anymore sence it was flooded so long ago, but it is nice to know that some people (other than my family) still take intriest in the what had happend to the town and the people that lived there when it was flooded. thank you "

Report Abuse

Lynda Henderson wrote on Jul 14, 2007 5:09 PM:

" They don't come any better than Elaine and Jimmy MacDonnell. They've endured a lot and always kept a positive outlook which they have passed on to their children. We miss Jimmy and all his wonderful stories about the early years. Thanks for taking the time to speak to this outstanding woman and share her story. "

Report Abuse

word warrior wrote on Jul 14, 2007 8:34 AM:

" Thought Mr. Brown's Camanche story was great. One question comes to mine. That area was the site of many Chinese graves. In those days Chinese were buried with a 'clay' jar whose contents included a gold coin. Never read or heard if these containers were reburied intact with the remains. Of course they were, including the 100-year old pure gold coins. "

Report Abuse

Comments on this story are now closed.

Archives

Story Tools

Indexes