Connecting You to Your Community
Lodi, California •

Story Tools

Email this story | Print this story

Indexes

November 30th, 2008
November 29th, 2008
November 28th, 2008
November 27th, 2008
November 26th, 2008
November 25th, 2008
November 24th, 2008
ADVERTISEMENT
Doctor Jerold J. Yecies discusses the problems with toxic mold, like the mold at Tokay High School, on Friday morning. Dr. Yecies is an allergist in the Lodi and Stockton area. (Whitney Ramirez/News-Sentinel)

'Toxic mold' is a myth, claims local allergy specialist

By Amanda Dyer
News-Sentinel Staff Writer
Updated: Saturday, June 30, 2007 5:38 AM PDT

After studying at Johns Hopkins University, Dr. Jerold J. Yecies has spent more than 30 years treating patients with allergies in the Lodi and Stockton areas.

Yecies said that while so-called "toxic" mold was controversial 10 to 15 years ago, most doctors now have agreed that there are no known allergies to black or toxic mold.

In the wake of the Tokay High School's recent mold discoveries Yecies sat down with reporter Amanda Dyer to talk about some of the health effects of mold and the myth of "toxic" mold.

Q: What are some reactions people have to molds?

A: There's a big difference between patients allergic to mold and toxic mold.

Toxic mold is black and it looks terrible, but there's never been shown ... (to be a) specific allergic reaction to toxic mold.

People do get what they call hypersensitivity reactions, which means they can have (reactions), just like you're sensitive to any irritant — sneezy, stuffy, headache, cough.

Q: Why is it called "toxic," then?

A: It's really a misnomer. What they're proposing is that it's not toxic. It's really what they call "damp building syndrome." ...

The main damage is if they don't fix this mold problem, be it in a home or a school, it's sort of like a dry rot. It keeps spreading and it will do damage to the structure.

Q: So, you can only get sick from mold if you're allergic to it?

A: If your allergic to it. We can do allergy tests for the various molds in this area, which we do. And people do have mold induced asthma, nasal and sinus problems, which we can document.

But this "toxic mold" is more of an irritant. You've maybe been into areas that smell musty or damp. They irritate you. You may start to cough, maybe sneezy, stuffy, congested, whatever. So, you leave because you feel better when you're away from it. But there's no actual scientific way to prove that.

It's more of an irritant type, or what we call a hypersensitivity. Just like you would be to perfume smell or any strong irritant.

Q: If you're allergic to mold, not necessarily black mold, what are the range of symptoms you can have from the most benign to the most severe?

A: You can have nasal stuffiness, congestion. The most severe would be significant and severe asthma. You can also, not from the toxic mold, but from mold spores, you can get a hypersensitivity lung disease, which is seen in some farmers. And that gives you an asthma, pneumonia type picture. Patients can be pretty sick with that.

Q: If someone is exposed to mold or fears that they have allergies to it, what should they do?

A: Well first, with any type of allergy you try to avoid what you're allergic to. In other words, if you have mold in the house or a leak, you try to clean it up.

If mold is outside — and, of course if you go outside you can't avoid that it's in the air — obviously you breathe it in.

We would then treat the patient that is allergic to the mold, that is determined by the various allergy tests, with medication. Not to help specifically the mold, but to help the symptoms.

If that does not work or work well enough, then you can desensitize or make someone less allergic to airborne mold by immunization or so-called allergy shots.

Q: What are some of the most common molds?

A: The ones that are common are alternaria, cladosporium and there are several others that are known to cause allergic reactions. In addition, you may have stachybotrys that doesn't cause (allergic reactions).

But patients don't care. If they're in an area where they're having trouble, or have increased symptoms they, frankly, don't care what type of mold it is. They want to be removed from that environment or treated. Both actually.

Q: Is this a good area for mold or a bad area?

A: The mold counts for the valley here are higher in the winter. But they're not as high as they would be in, say, Santa Cruz or along the coast, where it's damp and foggy and misty most of the year.

So, the mold counts over there are much higher and last much longer than they do in the valley.

Q: What are the oddest things that you've seen people be allergic to?

A: A patient can be allergic to anything, and I've learned not to discount what a patient says. Certainly peanuts, eggs, fish, shrimp are the more common allergens.

There are single allergens. We've had patients have reactions to ... one the other day was carrot. It's a very common, easily innocuous vegetable, but, yes, they definitely were allergic to a carrot.

Contact reporter Amanda Dyer at amandad@lodinews.com.

Reader Feedback

bobby wrote on Jul 9, 2007 11:49 AM:

" The Doctor makes an important point about "damp" buildings. Damp buildings can lead to not only mold but bacteria growth, chemical emissions(construction materials), dust mites, and other insect infestations. We tend to overlook the other things and just focus on mold growth. Bottom line is to fix the moisture intrusion problem first, remove the biological growth, and defective materials. Mold is serious and I don't think the doctor was trying to make light of it, he's mainly giving you the facts. "

Gary wrote on Jul 3, 2007 9:14 AM:

" Mold absolutely makes people sick, and school districts are notorious for allowing extensive leakage. The health affects are cumulative in people exposed over long periods of time. Administrators feel it's cheaper to let a few people get sick than it is to maintain the buildings properly in the first place. They out-lawyer sick people with valid claims and use junk science to confuse the public. Doctors like this one are appalling examples of poor medical training. "

RJH wrote on Jul 2, 2007 12:19 PM:

" This doctor isn't qualified to comment on mold effects on humans. This is a toxicology issue. I take issue with his statement, "I've learned not to discount what a patient says." He's clearly closed his mind to the type 3 allergy effects of mold. He's describing only type 1 symptoms. Vincent Marinkovich is imminently more qualified, and has written about this very issue. Dr. Yecies and just plain wrong. "

moldvictim2 wrote on Jul 2, 2007 9:26 AM:

" Obviously people who call mold related exposures nonsense have not been forced into disability because of the related consequences...chemical intolerance, chronic fatigue, organ damage, etc. Once you see people getting inflammatory diseases from the mycotoxins like MS and autoimmune diseases like lupus, one CANNOT ignore the damage it does to human health. How many more people will lose their health due to this ongoing denial? "

CS wrote on Jul 1, 2007 9:42 PM:

" I've never had a mold problem myself. I've seen people get sick from it because they have a leak in the house that caused mold to grow inside the walls. It robbed them of enjoyment of life and most of their savings. Suing anyone is hard and expensive and most builder contracts have arbitration clauses that PREVENT suing. The doctor in this article seems to be either ignorant or shilling for the industry. I read press releasses from businesses daily, and many of these are repackaged as "news" by the media. "

Richard Wolf, CEO Mold Remedies wrote on Jun 30, 2007 11:52 PM:

" I feel your Title maybe misleading, most people will misinterpret it and think that since toxic mold is a myth other molds are not an issue. We have been providing mold remediation for over a decade and believe me mold allergies are a serious health issue. Dr. Vecies is correct the term “toxic mold” or “black mold” is a misnomer, yet it is commonly used when describing the issue. Yet, it doesn’t mean that what is being described may not be a highly allergic and health damaging mold colony. "

Aunt Bernice wrote on Jun 30, 2007 6:35 PM:

" Maybe he studied at John Hopkins, but he must have got his degree from a vending machine. I have personally witnessed several people collapse from breathing problems brought on from working in a "mold" infested building. I wouldn't let this doctor treat my dog. "

Whoa Nellie! wrote on Jun 30, 2007 4:19 PM:

" OMG! T&C and I agree on something! The sky must be falling! "

SB wrote on Jun 30, 2007 3:37 PM:

" The EPA has produced an extensive handbook for physicians so they will know what to do with environmental exposures to toxins, called Guidance for Clinician on the Recognition and Management of Health Effects Related to Mold Exposure and Moisture Indoors, found on epa.gov. We need to have ALL of our physicians educated on this topic, as millions of people are sickened by mold each year. For reliable research and a comprehensive source of information on toxic mold and its impact on America's schools and occupants, visit www.schoolmoldhelp.org. "

Strongly Disagree wrote on Jun 30, 2007 3:36 PM:

" Mycotoxins (poisons) from common building molds are used in biological warfare. People don't have to be allergic to become very ill. The Institute of Medicine, in Damp Indoor Spaces and Health, 2004, said "Bacteria and Fungi can cause allergic responses, non-allergic, toxic and inflammatory effects" (p.7). Physicians are generally not trained on the toxic effects of molds or chemicals in medical schools. Physician associations have adopted position statements that deny the toxic effects of mold, described in the Wall Street Journal, Court of Opinion Amid Suits Over Mold, Experts Wear Two Hats, January 9, 2007. http://www.imakenews.com/pureaircontrols/e_article000741671.cfm?x=b8V9g0h,bvtvC3 "

T & C wrote on Jun 30, 2007 3:21 PM:

" I'll bet he's got people dying to get an appointment! LOL "

Darlene wrote on Jun 30, 2007 2:32 PM:

" I would say, put these physicians in a room with mold victim's, see what the outcome is. Education is the key here, this shows lack of, bottom line: Who needs the knowledge here, surely not the mold victim's. "

Finally........ wrote on Jun 30, 2007 1:54 PM:

" Someone has had the courage to say it. Toxic Mold is nonsense, There has always been mold theres always gonna be mold. Some people are alergic. Im allergic to pollen maybe we should tear out all the trees! "

Sharon wrote on Jun 30, 2007 12:49 PM:

" This is a great example as to why the mold issue never goes away. U have one who knows about allergies, speaking out of his field of study about symptoms of poisoning from toxins. U have one who is upset that wrong info is causing the sick to be unable to obtain treatment. One who thinks the first commenter only wants money for fake illness, thereby harming the school finances. Illness will become worse from lack of treatment. Damages will increase along with liability for the school. So sad. "

Taxpayer & Citizen wrote on Jun 30, 2007 12:07 PM:

" There was nothing wrong with asbestosis for years, either. Just what do you call mesolothemia? There was nothing with fiberglass for years, either. Why are people dying from breathing it without respirators on. I guess there's nothing to mold, either. Just a government conspiracy, right OSkkkAR "

Whoa Nellie! wrote on Jun 30, 2007 8:58 AM:

" cont... I have this sensitivity to damp & musty places, perfumes, etc. I think this doctor is a quack. That's why you see 1000's of cases on the news about crappy built homes having toxic mold and how many of these residents have health issues. This doctor is living in the 70's before this was an issue. "

Whoa Nellie! wrote on Jun 30, 2007 8:55 AM:

" They irritate you. You may start to cough, maybe sneezy, stuffy, congested, whatever. So, you leave because you feel better when you're away from it...You can have nasal stuffiness, congestion. The most severe would be significant and severe asthma. You can also, not from the toxic mold, but from mold spores, you can get a hypersensitivity lung disease, which is seen in some farmers. And that gives you an asthma, pneumonia type picture. Patients can be pretty sick with that." Huh? WTF? So mold is OK? "

Oscar wrote on Jun 30, 2007 6:30 AM:

" Thanks Dr. Yecies for you candid and honest remarks. I believe the mold problem is over exaggerated. Take the money out of the lawsuits and it's amazing to see how the problem goes away. As stated earlier, there's probably more mold in your bathroom than there is in any of these classrooms but we will spend millions of dollars correcting what a good ol Chlorox and warm water clean up could accomplish. I don't blame LUSD for what they have to do but I think it's unnecessary. "

Comments on this story are now closed.